Comments You Will Not Hear at the 10-09-11 WT Study (AUGUST 15, 2011, pages 12-16)(FOUND MESSIAH)
Review comments will be headed by COMMENTS
WT material from today's WT will be in black
Quotes from other sources will be indented and identified
w = Watchtower
g = Awake
jv = Proclaimers book
EXCELLENT GENERAL WEBSITE: www.jwfacts.com
Bible translations www.biblegateway.com/cgi-bin/bible
WT publications www.strictlygenteel.co.uk
WT child abuse www.silentlambs.org
Blood issue www.ajwrb.org
United Nations http://www.randytv.com/secret/unitednations.htm
Also posted on
http://exjehovahswitnessforum.yuku.com
http://www.jwsupportforum.com/index.php
http://www.jehovahswitnessrecovery.com/
THEY FOUND THE MESSIAH!
“We have found the Messiah.”—JOHN 1:41.
OPENING COMMENTS
Quite a boring article this week…what is the WTS motive? Most jws know a few of the prophecies regarding the Messiah and how they were seen to be fulfilled in Jesus, but then non-jws can do the same, those with a Christian background. Both groups agree that Jesus was the Messiah and these prophecies were fulfilled in him. Both do both groups believe the same in regard to the fulfillment of the prophecies about Jesus’ return, when and how? Not a chance.
How many jws know that the WTS taught that Christ returned, was present invisibly in 1874, later changed to 1914, and began reigning in 1878, later changed to 1914? Or that 1914 was the end and the wicked and human governments would be destroyed in 1914, not the beginning of the end?
Can jws (Bible Students from 1874 to 1931) believe the WTS explanations of Messianic prophecies from 1874 to today?
START OF ARTICLE
1. What led up to the statement: “We have found
the Messiah”?
JOHN THE BAPTIZER is standing with
two of his disciples. As Jesus approaches,
John exclaims: “See, the Lamb of God!” Andrew and
the other disciple promptly follow
Jesus and spend the day with him. Later, Andrew
finds his brother, Simon Peter, and
leads him to Jesus after making the dramatic
announcement: “We have found the Messiah .”—
John 1:35-41.
COMMENTS
Did Jesus identify himself as the Messiah?
Did John the Baptist (now Baptizer per the WTS) identify Jesus as such?
Had Andrew and the other disciple seen the holy spirit come down on Jesus per the WTS or only John the Baptist?
2. How will we benefit from further examination of
Messianic prophecies?
2 As time passes, Andrew, Peter, and others
will have ample opportunity to delve
into the Scriptures and will unreservedly declare
that Jesus of Nazareth is the promised
Messiah. Our own faith in God’s Word and
his Anointed One will be bolstered as we
now continue our examination of Messianic
prophecies.
COMMENTS
Does the WTS encourage people to read the scriptures OR their publications to prove they are the FDS, the only true Christians since 1879?
Faith in God’s Word OR as explained by the WTS/FDS/GB in their publications?
“Look! Your King Is Coming”
3. What prophecies were fulfilled by Jesus’ triumphal
entry into Jerusalem?
3 The Messiah would make a triumphal
entry into Jerusalem. Zechariah’s prophecy
stated: “Be very joyful, O daughter of Zion.
Shout in triumph, O daughter of Jerusalem.
Look! Your king himself comes to you. He is
righteous, yes, saved; humble, and riding
upon an ass, even upon a full-grown animal
the son of a she-ass.” (Zech. 9:9) The psalmist
wrote: “Blessed be the One coming in
the name of Jehovah.” (Ps. 118:26) Jesus
could not have manipulated the crowd’s actions.
However, in fulfillment of prophecy,
that throng spontaneously cried out with
boundless joy. As you read the account, visualize
the scene and hear the happy voices.
—Read Matthew 21:4-9.
COMMENTS
Triumphal entrance compared to 1878.
**jv (Proclaimers book) chap. 28 p. 632 ***
Based on the premise that events of the first century might find parallels in related events later, they also concluded that if Jesus’ baptism and anointing in the autumn of 29 C.E. paralleled the beginning of an invisible presence in 1874, then his riding into Jerusalem as King in the spring of 33 C.E. would point to the spring of 1878 as the time when he would assume his power as heavenly King. They also thought they would be given their heavenly reward at that time. When that did not occur, they concluded that since Jesus’ anointed followers were to share with him in the Kingdom, the resurrection to spirit life of those already sleeping in death began then. It was also reasoned that the end of God’s special favor to natural Israel down to 36 C.E. might point to 1881 as the time when the special opportunity to become part of spiritual Israel would close.
Could not have manipulated? What about the pregnant pause speakers at the conventions take signaling the jws in the audience to clap?
Does the WTS/FDS/GB come in the name of Jesus Christ or the name of Jehovah? While 1 st century followers were called Christians by divine providence by Rutherford’s providence WTS members have been called Jehovah’s witnesses…where is Christ in this?
4. Explain what happened in fulfillment of Psalm 118:22, 23.
4 Although many would reject Jesus despite
his Messianic credentials, he is precious to
God. As foretold, Jesus ‘was despised and
considered to be of no account’ by those
who refused to believe the evidence. (Isa.
53:3; Mark 9:12) However, God had inspired
the psalmist to say: “The stone that the
builders rejected has become the head of
the corner. This has come to be from Jehovah
himself.” (Ps.118:22, 23) Jesus drew this
passage to the attention of his religious opposers,
and Peter said that it was fulfilled in
Christ. (Mark 12:10, 11; Acts 4:8-11) Jesus
did become the “foundation cornerstone”
of the Christian congregation. Rejected by
godless men, he is “chosen, precious, with
God.”—1 Pet. 2:4-6.
COMMENTS
Doesn’t the WTS/FDS/GB every year tell all but 11,000 out of over 7,000,000 at the “Memorial (the REJECT JESUS PARTY), not to partake, to reject Jesus? Only partakers are jws, only anointed jws no one else, especially not non-jws.
***w09 1/15 p. 29 par. 16 ***
Not being in the new covenant and therefore not having the hope of living in heaven, these other sheep do not partake of the Memorial emblems but attend as respectful observers.
*** w96 8/15 p.31***
Over the years some, even ones newly baptized, have suddenly begun to partake. In a number of cases, after a while they acknowledged that this was an error. Some have recognized that they partook as an emotional response to perhaps physical or mental strain. But they came to see that they really were not called to heavenly life.
Don’t the jws reject Jesus Christ every time they identify themselves as jws rather than Christians?
Betrayed and Abandoned!
5, 6. What was foretold and fulfilled regarding the
Messiah’s betrayal?
5 It was foretold that the Messiah would be
betrayed by a treacherous associate. David
prophesied: “The man at peace with me, in
whom I trusted, who was eating my bread,
has magnified his heel against me.” (Ps.
41:9) A person who ate bread with someone
was thought to be his friend. (Gen. 31:54) So
the betrayal of Jesus by Judas Iscariot was
treachery of the worst sort. Jesus called attention
to the fulfillment of David’s prophetic words
when He referred to his betrayer and told
his apostles: “I am not talking about all of
you; I know the ones I have chosen.
But it is in order that the Scripture might be fulfilled,
‘He that used to feed on my bread has lifted up his heel
against me.’”—John 13:18.
COMMENTS
Since a close follower of Jesus had to sin to fulfill this prophecy, then one of the 12 had to be the one. Was there a choice then for this man or was he doomed and in the words of the WTS, the WTS pronounces eternal death on Judas’ head.
*** it-2 p.792***
Jesus Christ said that one who sinned against the holy spirit would not be forgiven in the present system of things nor in that to come. (Mt 12:31, 32) A person whom God judged as having sinned against the holy spirit in the present system of things would therefore not profit by a resurrection, since his sins would never be forgiven, making resurrection useless for him. Jesus uttered judgment against Judas Iscariot in calling him “the son of destruction.” The ransom would not apply to him, and his destruction already being a judicially established judgment, he would not receive a resurrection.—Joh 17:12.
David was the one that was treacherous, stealing another man’s wife and then having him put to death to cover up his sin, a sin worthy of execution. So did David picture Jesus or Judas?
Can a person betray the WTS to be true to Christ? I do believe so.
6 The Messiah’s betrayer would receive 30
pieces of silver—the price of a slave!
Drawing on Zechariah 11:12, 13,
Matthew showed that Jesus was betrayed
for such a paltry sum. But why did Matthew
say that this had been foretold “through Jeremiah
the prophet”? In Matthew’s day, Jeremiah may have been
placed first in a group of Bible books that included
Zechariah. (Compare Luke 24:44.)
Judas never spent his ill-gotten sum, for he
threw the money into the temple and went
off and committed suicide.—Matt. 26:14-16;
27:3-10.
COMMENTS
MAY HAVE BEEN—have you ever noticed how often the WTS adds to the bible?
7. How did Zechariah 13:7 undergo fulfillment?
7 Even the Messiah’s disciples would scatter.
“Strike the shepherd,” wrote Zechariah,
“and let those of the flock be scattered.”
(Zech. 13:7) On Nisan 14, 33 C.E., Jesus told
his disciples: “All of you will be stumbled in
connection with me on this night, for it is
written, ‘I will strike the shepherd, and
the sheep of the flock will be scattered
about.’” And that is exactly what happened,
for Matthew reported that “all the disciples
abandoned [Jesus] and fled.”—Matt. 26:
31, 56.
COMMENTS
Why the brackets [Jesus]?
Also why were the disciples following a man and not God, after all they were Jews, not Gentiles?
Jesus’ triumphal entry into Jerusalem fulfilled which prophecies?
Accused and Smitten
8. Under what circumstances was Isaiah 53:8 fulfilled?
8 The Messiah would be tried and
condemned. (Read Isaiah 53:8.) At dawn on
Nisan 14, the entire Sanhedrin met, had Jesus
bound, and handed him over to Roman
Governor Pontius Pilate. He questioned Jesus
and found him guilty of nothing at all.
When Pilate offered to release Jesus, however,
the crowd shouted: “Impale him!” and
called for the freeing of the criminal Barabbas.
Wishing to satisfy the throng, Pilate released
Barabbas, had Jesus whipped, and
handed him over to be impaled.—Mark 15:
1-15.
COMMENTS
Rutherford must have seen himself in this picture when he was put in prison in 1918, but was he guilty of nothing, was he exonerated as he claimed? Remember there was an inflammatory section in the Finished Mystery that the WTS cut out to be able to keep selling this book.
http://www.jehovahs-witness.net/jw/friends/28327/1/Was-J-F-Rutherford-Exonerated
9. What happened in Jesus’ time as was foretold at
Psalm 35:11?
9 False witnesses would testify against the
Messiah. “Violent witnesses rise up,” said
the psalmist David. “What I have not
known they ask me.” (Ps. 35:11) True to
prophecy, “the chief priests and the entire
Sanhedrin were looking for false witness
against Jesus in order to put him to
death.” (Matt. 26:59) In fact, “many, indeed,
were giving false witness against him, but
their testimonies were not in agreement.”
(Mark 14:56) Lying testimony mattered little
to Jesus’ rabid enemies, who sought his
death.
COMMENTS
How does the WTS view lying?
*** w07 2/1 p.6***
Every lie is an untruth, but not every untruth is a lie. Why not? A dictionary defines a lie as “an assertion of something known or believed by the speaker to be untrue with intent to deceive.” Yes, lying includes the intention to deceive someone. Hence, to speak an untruth unwittingly—such as giving someone incorrect facts or figures by mistake—is not the same as to tell a lie.
Moreover, we need to consider whether the person asking for information is entitled to a comprehensive answer. For instance, suppose Manfred had been asked the same questions by an executive of another company. Would Manfred have been obliged to tell him everything? Not really. Since that executive had no right to such information, Manfred would have had no obligation to provide it. Of course, even in this case, it would have been wrong for him to tell a lie.
10. Explain how Isaiah 53:7 was fulfilled.
10 The Messiah would be silent before his
accusers. Isaiah prophesied: “He was hard
pressed, and he was letting himself be afflicted;
yet he would not open his mouth.
He was being brought just like a sheep to the
slaughtering; and like a ewe that before her
shearers has become mute, he also would
not open his mouth.” (Isa. 53:7) While Jesus
“was being accused by the chief priests and
older men, he made no answer.” Pilate
asked: “Do you not hear how many things
they are testifying against you?” Nevertheless,
Jesus “did not answer him, no, not
a word, so that the governor wondered
very much.” (Matt. 27:12-14) Jesus did not
revile his accusers.—Rom. 12:17-21; 1 Pet.
2:23.
COMMENTS
There is something to be said about this. I use the phrase “no pearls before swine” to illustrate whether I will answer certain posters and why I have no desire to talk to the elders about the flaws in their and the WTS teachings.
11. What took place in fulfillment of Isaiah 50:6
and Micah 5:1?
11 Isaiah prophesied that the Messiah
would be smitten. “My back I gave to the
strikers, and my cheeks to those plucking off
the hair,” wrote the prophet. “My face I
did not conceal from humiliating things
and spit.” (Isa. 50:6) Micah foretold: “With
the rod they will strike upon the cheek the
judge of Israel.” (Mic. 5:1) Confirming the
fulfillment of these prophecies, the Gospel
writer Mark said: “Some started to spit on
[Jesus] and to cover his whole face and hit
him with their fists and say to him: ‘Prophesy!’
And, slapping him in the face, the court
attendants took him.” Mark states that soldiers
“would hit him on the head with
a reed and spit upon him and, bending
their knees [in mockery] , they would do
obeisance to him.” (Mark 14:65; 15:19) Of
course, Jesus did nothing to provoke such
abuse.
COMMENTS
Brackets 2 more times…does every NWT have these?
Who does those who label some ex-jws “mentally diseased” resemble, Jesus or the soldiers who were “mocking” him?
Faithful to Death
12. How did Psalm 22:16 and Isaiah 53:12 apply to
Jesus?
12 Aspects of the Messiah’s impalement
were foretold. “The assembly of evildoers
themselves have enclosed me,” said the
psalmist David. “Like a lion they are at my
hands and my feet.” (Ps. 22:16) Reporting an
event well-known to Bible readers, the Gospel
writer Mark states: “It was now the third
hour [about nine o’clock in the morning],
and they impaled him.” (Mark 15:25) It had
also been foretold that the Messiah would
be numbered with sinners. “He poured out
his soul to the very death,” wrote Isaiah,
“and it was with the transgressors that he
was counted in.” (Isa. 53:12) So it was that
“two robbers were impaled with [Jesus] , one
on his right and one on his left.”—Matt.
27:38.
COMMENTS
Two more sets of brackets…is this dumbing down?
When humans labeling others as “sinners” they step beyond God; will they receive the same judgment they give out?
13. In what way was Psalm 22:7, 8 fulfilled in Jesus?
13 David prophesied that the Messiah
would be reviled. (Read Psalm 22:7, 8.) Jesus
was reviled while suffering on the torture
stake, for Matthew reports: “The passersby
began speaking abusively of him, wagging
their heads and saying: ‘O you would-be
thrower-down of the temple and builder of
it in three days, save yourself! If you are a
son of God, come down off the torture
stake!’ ” Similarly, the chief priests, scribes,
and older men made fun of him and said:
“Others he saved; himself he cannot save!
He is King of Israel; let him now come down
off the torture stake and we will believe on
him. He has put his trust in God; let Him
now rescue him if He wants him, for
he said, ‘I am God’s Son.’” (Matt.
27:39-43) Yet, Jesus bore all of this
with dignity. What a fine example
for us!
COMMENTS
So even an adulterer and a murderer can prophesy.
So when it came out about the “mentally diseased,” how did so called faithful jws respond, abusively. They are just as arrogant as to their status with God.
14, 15. Show how specific prophecies were fulfilled
regarding the Messiah’s clothing and his being given
vinegar.
14 Lots were to be cast for the Messiah’s
clothing. “They apportion my
garments among themselves,” wrote
the psalmist, “and upon my clothing
they cast lots.” (Ps. 22:18) That is
what occurred, for “when [the Roman
soldiers] had impaled [Jesus] they
distributed his outer garments by casting
lots.”—Matt. 27:35; read John 19:
23, 24.
COMMENTS
More brackets and evidence of dumbing down…are they afraid that the rank and file don’t know how to look it up in the Insight volumes?
15 The Messiah would be given vinegar and
gall. “For food they gave me a
poisonous plant,” said the psalmist,
“and for my thirst they tried to make
me drink vinegar.” (Ps. 69:21) Matthew
tells us: “They gave [Jesus] wine
mixed with gall to drink; but, after tasting it,
he refused to drink.” Later, “one of them ran
and took a sponge and soaked it with sour
wine and put it on a reed and went giving
him a drink.”—Matt. 27:34, 48.
COMMENTS
More brackets…who else could this scripture be talking about?
Jesus died for our sins, but he now rules as Messianic King
16. Explain how the prophetic words of Psalm 22:1
were fulfilled.
16 The Messiah would seem forsaken by
God. (Read Psalm 22:1.) In accord with
prophecy, “at the ninth hour [about
three o’clock in the afternoon] Jesus called
out with a loud voice: ‘Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?’
which means, when translated: ‘My
God, my God, why have you forsaken me?’”
(Mark 15:34) Jesus had not lost faith in his
heavenly Father. God abandoned Jesus to
his enemies by taking away His protection
so that Christ’s integrity might be fully tested.
And by crying out as he did, Jesus fulfilled
Psalm 22:1.
COMMENTS
More brackets…..
So if humans reject us, does that mean God has?
17. How were Zechariah 12:10 and Psalm 34:20 fulfilled?
17 The Messiah would be pierced, but his
bones would not be broken. Inhabitants of Jerusalem
would “look to the One whom
they pierced through.” (Zech. 12:10) And
Psalm 34:20 states: “ [God] is guarding all
the bones of that one; not one of them has
been broken.” Confirming these points, the
apostle John wrote: “One of the soldiers
jabbed his [Jesus’] side with a spear, and immediately
blood and water came out. And
he that has seen it [John] has borne witness,
and his witness is true . . . These things took
place in order for the scripture to be fulfilled:
‘Not a bone of his will be crushed.’
And, again, a different scripture says: ‘They
will look to the One whom they pierced.’ ”
—John 19:33-37.
COMMENTS
More brackets………
How many jws knew these scriptures pertained to the Messiah. How many know what prophecies today apply per the WTS? How many can explain the 607/1914 prophecy? How many know that the originating date was 606 at one point?
18. How did Jesus come to be buried with the rich?
18 The Messiah would be buried with the
rich. (Read Isaiah 53:5, 8, 9.) Late in the afternoon
of Nisan 14, “a rich man of Arimathea,
named Joseph,” asked Pilate for Jesus’
body, and the request was granted. Matthew’s
account adds: “Joseph took the body,
wrapped it up in clean fine linen, and laid it
in his new memorial tomb, which he had
quarried in the rock-mass. And, after rolling
a big stone to the door of the memorial
tomb, he left.”—Matt. 27:57-60.
COMMENTS
Yes, Joseph could not standup for Christ when he was alive. I wonder if he was like the secret non-jws today?
Hail the Messianic King!
19. What happened in keeping with the prophetic
words of Psalm 16:10?
19 The Messiah would be resurrected. David
wrote: “You [Jehovah] will not leave my
soul in Sheol.” (Ps. 16:10) Imagine the surprise
of the women who came to the tomb
where Jesus’ body had been laid. There they
encountered a materialized angel, who told
them: “Stop being stunned. You are looking
for Jesus the Nazarene, who was impaled. He
was raised up, he is not here. See! The place
where they laid him.” (Mark 16:6) To the
crowd present in Jerusalem on the day of
Pentecost 33 C.E., the apostle Peter declared:
“ [David] saw beforehand and spoke concerning
the resurrection of the Christ, that
neither was he forsaken in Hades nor did his
flesh see corruption.” (Acts 2:29-31) God
did not allow the physical body of his beloved
Son to decay. Moreover, Jesus was
miraculously raised to life in the spirit!
—1 Pet. 3:18.
COMMENTS
Even more brackets………….
Imagine that the women were braver than the men and the first to go to the tomb.
When Jesus did not return in the 19 th century in the flesh, his return was interpreted as invisible. Will the END be invisible then, which has been predicted for 1914, 1915, 1920, 1925, 1940’s, 1975, (1984), (1994)….perhaps 2014 (100 years from 1914), or 2034 (120 years from 1914), or even farther out now that the old 1914 generation has become two overlapping generations.
20. How was the foretold rulership of the Messiah
fulfilled?
20 As foretold, God declared that Jesus is
his Son. (Read Psalm 2:7; Matthew 3:17.)
Also, crowds hailed Jesus and the coming
Kingdom, and we joyfully speak about
him and his blessed rule. (Mark 11:7-10)
Christ will soon destroy his foes as he ‘rides
in the cause of truth, humility, and righteousness.’
(Ps. 2:8, 9; 45:1-6) His kingship
will then bring about earth-wide peace and
prosperity. (Ps. 72:1, 3, 12, 16; Isa. 9:6, 7)
How privileged we are to proclaim these
truths as Witnesses of Jehovah, whose beloved
Son already reigns in heaven as the Messianic King!
COMMENTS
SOON…1874 to 2011 (137 years and counting)
His foes---all non-jws, over 7 billion men, women, and children, destroyed eternally
Witnesses of Jehovah or Christians—where is Jesus in the WTS equation?
Already reigns---1878 or 1914?
How Would You Answer?
? How was Jesus betrayed and abandoned?
? What were some foretold features
of Jesus Christ’s impalement?
? Why are you convinced that Jesus
is the promised Messiah?
CONCLUDING COMMENTS
So did you know that prophecy can be understood before the event, during the event, and after the event? The WTS has an excellent CYA measure.
Next week, JEHOVAH—“THE GOD WHO GIVES PEACE.”
Love, Blondie