There were always brown-noses, but I found more often than not that Elders would push their 'friends' up the ladder to MS and Elders.
For instance, there was one Elder who pushed his Son-In-Law up the ladder to an MS and Elder, despite showing no effort or enthusiasm whatsoever but he became one none-the-less.
The S-I-L was the most miserable people you could ever wish to meet and completely unapproachable. He never said hello to anyone, came to the meetings, did his talks and other responsibilities and disappeared straight away when the meeting closed. I'm sure we've all met Elders like that.
I remember once that it came to light that the Elders all played golf together and occasionally would invite other 'Brothers' to tag along. These 'Brothers' would often be appointed within a short period of time which again indicated that Elder's would recommend certain JW's for positions of responsibility because they socialised with them. It was nothing to do with Holy Spirit appointing them or because they were 'reaching out'.
The same Elder (above) pushed his own study all the way to be a MS and then later an Elder. Again, it was nothing to do with this individual 'reaching out', it was purely because this Elder wanted a feather in his cap.
After he was appointed, he smugly made reference saying that he was the 'jewel' in ***** crown'. Says it all really.
He was lazy, arrogant, tell his wife private congregation business, caused divisions in the book group, and would often not turn up for talks. He was the biggest snitch going and would deliberately cause rifts by revealing private conversations.
At the time I was reaching out to be an MS and he put every obstacle in my way. I even found out that he had recommended that I shouldn't be made up as I wasn't a Pioneer. Yet at the time, I was running the sound by myself (sound Servant was never at meetings), putting in over 20+ hours a month, doing talks on the MS, reading the Watchtower, prayers, you name it, I was doing it.
Eventually, he had all my priviledges removed because I didn't turn up to read at the bookgroup one night. He went to the other Elders and said that I was 'unreliable'.
I then met someone at work and started a relationship with her. It was at that time I was put on a judicial comittee and reproved. He loved every minute of it but following that I never reached out again and slowly started to fade.
I made the mistake of marrying a JW in haste, thinking that would keep me a JW. The truth is she wanted out of it as much as I did and eventually we both stopped attending meetings. We had a turbulent marriage that ended in 2007.
Sorry for the ramble. ;)