Comments You Will Not Hear at the 04-29-2012 WT Study (FEBRUARY 15, 2012, pages 26-30)(DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD)
Review comments will be headed by COMMENTS
WT material from today's WT will be in black
Quotes from other sources will be indented and identified
w = Watchtower
g = Awake
jv = Proclaimers book
EXCELLENT GENERAL WEBSITE : www.jwfacts.com
Bible translations www.biblegateway.com/cgi-bin/bible
WT publications www.strictlygenteel.co.uk
WT child abuse www.silentlambs.org
Blood issue www.ajwrb.org
United Nations http://www.randytv.com/secret/unitednations.htm
Also posted on
http://exjehovahswitnessforum.yuku.com
http://www.jwsupportforum.com/index.php
http://www.jehovahswitnessrecovery.com/
HAPPINESS IS POSSIBLE
IN A DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD
“How do you know but that you will
save your [mate]?”—1 COR. 7:16.
HAPPINESS IS POSSIBLE
IN A DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD
CAN YOU FIND THE ANSWERS?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What can believers do to
cultivate peace in a religiously
divided home?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
How might a Christian help
unbelieving family members
to embrace true worship?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What can others do to help
fellow believers who live in religiously
divided households?
OPENING COMMENTS
I am somewhat of an expert in the topic of “divided” households. I grew up in one for 30 years. Years of being treated as spiritually bad association just because my father was worldly, not invited to the witness parties, being assigned to other people from “divided” families to go door to door, missing meetings because my father would visit friends out of town, Basically belonging to the group we children of non-jws called THE REJECTS. The term “divided household” is not even in the bible.
I always hated and still do that term “divided.” I knew a couple with children married 60 years happily with well adjusted children, except the father was not and never wanted to be a jw. Whereas I saw jw families both parents jws with yelling, abuse, lying, cheating. That stopped my thinking if my father were a jw our family abuse would go away.
START OF ARTICLE
1. What effect can acceptance of the Kingdom message have
on a family?
WHEN Jesus sent out his apostles on one
occasion, he said: “As you go, preach,
saying, ‘The kingdom of the heavens has
drawn near.’ ” (Matt. 10:1, 7) This good news would
bring peace and happiness to those accepting it
with true appreciation. However, Jesus warned his
apostles that many would oppose their Kingdom preaching
work. (Matt. 10:16-23) An especially painful
form of opposition is experienced when family
members reject the Kingdom message.—Read Matthew
10:34-36.
COMMENTS
See how the WTS sets up its statements to eliminate so-called Christian non-jws? “true appreciation” and judged by the WTS as to what is true.
Was the WTS and is the WTS persecuted for preaching “the kingdom”? How many non-jws even here the word “kingdom” come out of the mouths of jws at the door. In the monthly kingdom ministries the WTS provides 4 presentations for their publications that month, and rarely does that word, kingdom, appear.
Really the WTS preaches that soon God will destroy all governments on earth and only the WTS/jws will remain…a concept that most likely brings resistance from those governments. Are family members rejecting the kingdom or the WTS and its interpretation that only they represent God and the kingdom?
Check this website, www.forum18.org , and find that the WTS is not the only “persecuted” religious group.
2. Why is happiness not out of reach for Christians who live
in religiously divided households?
2 Does this mean that happiness is out of reach
for Christ’s followers who live in religiously divided
households? Not at all! Though family opposition
can sometimes be severe, that is not always the
case. Then, too, family opposition is not necessarily
permanent. Much depends on how believers respond
to opposition or indifference. Moreover, Jehovah
blesses those who are loyal to him, making them
joyful despite unfavorable circumstances. Believers
can add to their own happiness (1) by endeavoring
to cultivate peace in the home and (2) by sincerely
trying to help unbelieving family members to embrace
true worship.
COMMENTS
But what the WTS fails to mention is how jws in divided households are viewed as spiritual danger to other jws. Is it automatic that non-jws married to jws persecute and oppose. I remember the stories about one sister, about whom it was said that her husband persecuted and beat her. Yet talking to non-jw friends and their grown jw children, they said that story was never true. I bet that story is still circulating with no one the wiser.
What about jws that abuse by name-calling, physical abuse, demeaning speech, controlling actions for example through finances and sex? The stories jw women told about their non-jw husbands and ex-husbands showed they were not applying “bible” principles; definitely not “sincerely trying to help unbelieving family members to embrace true worship.” Remember Peter said it was by their actions not their words they would win that person over.
CULTIVATE PEACE IN THE HOME
3. Why should a Christian in a divided household cultivate
peace?
3 For the seed of righteousness to bear fruit in
a family environment, peaceful conditions in the
home are essential. (Read James 3:18.) Even if a
Christian’s family is not yet unified in
pure worship, he must make an earnest
effort to cultivate peace in the home.
How can this be done?
A Christian? = only a jw
If you grew up in such a family, did your jw parent promote “peace”? If not, what did they do? Remember the people at the KH see nothing of what goes on at home, it is only the “word” of the jw; would the elders believe the non-jw? I can remember jw sisters complaining about their lot in life, including my mother. Imagine what the non-jw mate would think finding that out, would it make them want to become a jw knowing their personal life was entertainment?
4. How may Christians maintain their inner
peace?
4 Christians must maintain their inner
peace. This calls for heartfelt prayer,
which can bring us the incomparable
“peace of God.” (Phil. 4:6, 7) Happiness
and peace result from taking in knowledge
of Jehovah and applying Scriptural
principles in life. (Isa. 54:13) Participation
in congregation meetings and zealous
activity in the field ministry are also
vital if we are to enjoy peace and happiness.
Sharing in Christian activities in
some way is generally possible for believers
living in divided households. For
example, consider Enza,* whose husband
is violently opposed. She engages
in the disciple-making work after taking
care of her household duties. Enza says,
“Jehovah richly blesses me with good results
each time I make the effort to share
the good news with others.” Such blessings
certainly result in peace, satisfaction,
and happiness.
*Names have been changed.
COMMENTS
Christians = only jws (WTS calls the others “professed Christians” or “so-called Christians”)
Doesn’t John 17:3 include taking in knowledge of Jesus; this is what happens when you apply an OT scripture to Christians, Jesus is left out of the picture.
Participation in the meetings = not many jws are participating; in my last congregation out of 100 people only 5 regularly commented each Sunday, none brothers. With 6 elders, 2 MS, 5 regular pioneers, 6 elders wives, 19 people, why only these same 5 each week, not a one of that 19.
Violently opposed? – what does that mean, does he hit or beat her, yell at her, forbid her to go door to door, oh that’s right, she does go door to door but there is no indication that her husband is not aware of it, just that he wants her duties at home done first, no unreasonable.
5. What challenge do believers in divided
households often face, and what help is available?
5 We need to make an earnest effort
to cultivate a peaceful relationship with
unbelieving family members. This may
present a challenge because what they
want us to do may at times conflict with
Bible principles. Our holding firmly
to right principles may upset some unbelieving
family members, but such a
stand promotes peace in the long run.
Of course, being unyielding when something
does not violate Scriptural principles
may cause unnecessary friction.
(Read Proverbs 16:7.) When facing a
challenge, it is important to seek Scriptural
counsel from publications of the
faithful and discreet slave class and
from the elders.—Prov. 11:14.
COMMENTS
Does making a “peaceful relationship” mean talking about the “truth” non-stop, telling them not only will the jw not celebrate birthdays or holidays, but they tell the non-jw they can’t either, that they won’t engage in certain “sexual activity” (a WTS policy that can and has changed 5 years later), that their children cannot have a blood transfusion, that their children cannot go to college, imposing jw beliefs on the spouse?
No seeking of scriptural counsel from the BIBLE, but only WTS publications and the elders, WTS representatives?
The WTS teaches that the non-jw husband is still the “head” of his family. But somehow the first suggestion is to pray, be a better person (as if it is the victim’s fault), to make it “endurable.” So who “allows” it, god or the elders. (underline mine)
*** w88 11/1 p.22 par.11***
Extremephysical abuse is another basis for separation. Suppose an unbelieving mate often gets drunk, becomes enraged, and causes the believer physical harm. (Proverbs 23:29-35) Through prayer and by displaying the fruitage of Jehovah’s spirit, the believer may be able to prevent such outbursts and make the situation endurable. But if the point is reached where the health and life of the abused mate actually are in jeopardy, separation would be allowable Scripturally.
*** w88 11/1 p.26 par.3***
Naturally, separation or divorce should not be a foregone conclusion, since it may be possible to restore marital peace, and even adultery or other forms of fornication can be forgiven by an innocent marriage partner.—Matthew 5:31, 32; compare Hosea 3:1-3.
*** w86 7/1 p.6***
It is a similar situation with a family. If husbands or fathers should misuse their authority, we can be sure that God eventually will right such matters, not allowing any injustices to exist in his righteous new system soon to come. In the meantime, Christian women and children continue to respect the principle of Christian headship, even if it is sometimes abused. They appreciate that it is not meant to belittle but is designed to ensure peace and unity within both the family and the Christian congregation.—1 Corinthians 11:3.
*** w64 4/15 pp.249-250***
Real love for the family is shown by being willing to put up with disapproval, or even abuse, so that those unbelieving family members may have the best possible opportunity to learn the truths from God’s Word and come in line for the everlasting blessings that Jehovah God holds out to those who serve him.—1 Pet. 3:1-6.
6, 7. (a) Why do some oppose family members
who begin to study with Jehovah’s Witnesses?
(b) How should a Bible student or a believer
respond to family opposition?
6 Cultivating peace in a household
calls for trust in Jehovah and insight
into the feelings of unbelieving family
members. (Prov. 16:20) Even new Bible
students can show discernment in
this regard. Some unbelieving husbands
or wives may not object to having their
mate study the Bible. They may even acknowledge
that this could be good for
the family. Others, however, may manifest
hostility. Esther, who is now a Witness,
admits that she reacted in “pure
anger” when her husband began studying
the Bible with Jehovah’s Witnesses.
“I either threw out his literature
or burned it,” she says. Howard, who
at first opposed his wife’s Bible study,
remarks: “Many husbands are afraid
that their wives are being tricked into
joining a religious sect. A husband
may not know how to react to this supposed
threat and may become antagonistic.”
COMMENTS
But hasn’t the WTS called unbelieving family members, “corpses,” like it is just like kissing a dead corpse? I know because I was in the audience of the circuit assembly when the CO said that from the stage.
Did you as a jw encourage your bible student to tell their husband?
What does it mean to “manifest hostility”?
Does the average spouse want to see their mate spending 4 to 5 hours weekly at meetings, 2 hours door to door weekly, 2 to 3 hours personal study, going to assemblies/conventions all the time leaving the mate at home alone?
But jws are “tricking” people into joining a high control group and won’t answer questions until the “right” time for it, even after baptism when it is not possible to back out with religious group punishment?
7 A student whose mate is opposed
should be helped to see that he does
not have to discontinue his Bible study.
Often he will be able to resolve matters
by being mild-tempered and showing
respect for his unbelieving mate. (1 Pet.
3:15) Howard says, “I am so grateful
that my wife stayed calm and did not
overreact!” His wife explains: “Howard
demanded that I give up studying the
Bible. He said that I was being brainwashed.
Instead of arguing, I said that
he could be right, but I also told him that
I could not honestly see how. So I asked
him to read the book I was studying.
He did so and could not disagree with
what it said. This deeply affected him.”
It is good to remember that unbelieving
spouses may feel abandoned or threatened
when their mate leaves to participate
in Christian activities, but loving
reassurances can go a long way in allaying
such feelings.
COMMENTS
So is the WTS suggesting that the mate has not been showing respect all along and that is why their spouse is “opposed”? But how many people know that what is in the WTS books is window dressing and many times not what is practiced. But how would you know unless you join and their learn to your hurt and your family’s?
How would a jw wife feel if their husband spent that amount of time away from the family pursuing a hobby? Or pursued his own religious beliefs and included the children in it?
HELP THEM TO EMBRACE TRUE WORSHIP
8. What counsel did the apostle Paul give to
Christians who have unbelieving mates?
8 The apostle Paul advises Christians
not to leave a marriage partner just because
that individual is an unbeliever.*
(Read 1 Corinthians 7:12-16.) Keeping in
mind the possibility that an unbelieving
marriage mate may become a Christian
can help a believer to maintain his or
her happiness although living in a divided
household. In trying to reach the unbeliever
with the message of the truth,
though, a certain caution is in order, as
the following experiences bear out.
*Paul’s counsel does not rule out legal separation
in extreme situations. That is a serious personal
decision. See “Keep Yourselves in God’s Love,” pages
220-221.
COMMENTS
Remember, Christians = only jws
But jws will and have left a spouse that has been disfellowshipped (not for adultery) or has “disassociated themselves,” “unbeliever” does not mean ex-jw. Doesn’t 1 Peter 3:1,2 apply here too?
9. When introducing Bible truth to unbelieving
family members, what caution is in order?
9 Reflecting on his reaction to learning
Bible truth, Jason says, “I wanted
to tell everyone!” When a Bible student
comes to appreciate the truthfulness of
what he has been taught from the Scriptures,
he may be so happy that he talks
about it almost all the time. He may expect
unbelieving family members to accept
the Kingdom message immediately,
but the good news could be met with
an adverse response. How did Jason’s
initial enthusiasm affect his wife? “I felt
overwhelmed,” she recalls. One woman
who accepted the truth 18 years after
her husband did says, “I, for one, needed
to learn it gradually.” If you are presently
conducting a Bible study with a student
whose mate has no desire to take
part in true worship, why not hold regular
practice sessions to help the student
to approach issues tactfully? Moses said:
“My instruction will drip as the rain, my
saying will trickle as the dew, as gentle
rains upon grass.” (Deut. 32:2) A few
well-placed droplets of truth will often
do more good than a spiritual downpour
would.
COMMENTS
So does a non-jw spouse have 18 years today in the WTS timelime to learn it gradually?
Of course, the WTS is assuming that the jw knows how to approach things tactfully.
10-12. (a) What counsel did the apostle Peter
give to Christians who have unbelieving mates?
(b) How did one Bible student learn to apply
the counsel recorded at 1 Peter 3:1, 2?
10 The apostle Peter provided inspired
counsel for Christian wives living in religiously
divided households. “Be in
Choose the right time to explain your beliefs
subjection to your own husbands,” he
wrote, “in order that, if any are not obedient
to the word, they may be won
without a word through the conduct of
their wives, because of having been eyewitnesses
of your chaste conduct together
with deep respect.” (1 Pet. 3:1, 2) A
wife may be able to win her husband
over to true worship by being in subjection
and showing deep respect for him,
even if he treats her harshly. Likewise, a
believing husband should conduct himself
in a godly way and be a loving head
of the household despite any opposition
he may encounter from his unbelieving
wife.—1 Pet. 3:7-9.
COMMENTS
So how far does a woman go in subjection, allow physical and verbal abuse? How many punches does he get before it goes beyond “harshly”?
11 Many modern-day examples illustrate
the value of applying Peter’s counsel.
Consider the case of Selma. When
she began to study the Bible with Jehovah’s
Witnesses, her husband, Steve,
was not pleased. He admits, “I became
angry, jealous, possessive, and
insecure.” Selma observes: “Even before
I got the truth, living with Steve
was like walking on eggshells. He was
hot-tempered. When I started studying
the Bible, this characteristic intensified.”
What helped?
COMMENTS
So Selma’s husband was a problem before she started studying with jws, not because. “got the truth” where is that phrase in the bible; is that to imply everything outside the WT organization is false and they tell no lies.
http://www.jwfacts.com/watchtower/fear-cult-mind-control.php
12 Selma recalls a lesson she learned
from the Witness who studied with her.
“On one particular day,” says Selma, “I
didn’t want to have a Bible study. The
night before, Steve had hit me as I had
tried to prove a point, and I was feeling
sad and sorry for myself. After I told
the sister what had happened and how
I felt, she asked me to read 1 Corinthians
13:4-7. As I did, I began to reason,
‘Steve never does any of these loving
things for me.’ But the sister made me
think differently by asking, ‘How many
of those acts of love do you show toward
your husband?’ My answer was,
‘None, for he is so difficult to live with.’
The sister softly said, ‘Selma, who is
trying to be a Christian here? You or
Steve?’ Realizing that I needed to adjust
my thinking, I prayed to Jehovah to help
me be more loving toward Steve. Slowly,
things started to change.” After 17 years,
Steve accepted the truth.
COMMENTS
“The night before, Steve had hit me as I had
tried to prove a point, and I was feeling
sad and sorry for myself.”
So he hit her because she wasn’t loving enough; does that mean she could hit him if he weren’t “loving” enough? And once again do non-jws have 17 years before becoming jws; where is soon, very soon, very soon now, on the threshold?
So is there a one-hit rule for husbands? What if he had hit his female boss or female secretary at work, or hit a waitress at a restaurant who were all a little too mouthy? So is it wrong to hit those women but acceptable to hit his wife. Remember most men are physically stronger than their wives.
HOW OTHERS CAN HELP
13, 14. How can others in the congregation
assist those who live in a religiously divided
household?
13 Like gentle drops of rain that soak
the ground and help plants to grow,
many individuals in the congregation
contribute to the happiness of Christians
in divided households. “The love
of my brothers and sisters was what
helped me to stand firm in the truth,”
says Elvina in Brazil.
COMMENTS
The “individuals in the congregation” I attended contributed to my family’s happiness by avoiding us, shunning us, treating us a spiritual leprosy. Once we brought an in-law to a small picnic we had hosted and an elder at it showed us this “advice.” This person was not doing anything spiritually unacceptable (underline mine). My family were considered a danger because someone might have to have contact with my non-jw father although I saw many non-jws invited to this elders parties.
*** km 6/89 p.2 par.6***
We have been counseled to be cautious in our dealings with men of the nations, unbelievers, and ordinary persons. (See the November 15, 1988, issue of TheWatchtower, pages 15-16.) Why should we have unnecessary social contact with people who still pursue worldly ways and who have not become worshipers of Jehovah? (2 Cor. 6:14, 15) Some who are negligent spiritually may seek out others who also hold on to worldly thinking and ways instead of seeking association with mature Christians who could help them become strong in the faith. They fail to appreciate that attendance at social gatherings with worldly, unprincipled people can weaken their faith and corrupt them.—Compare 2 Thessalonians 3:14, 15.
14 Kindness and interest on the part of
others in the congregation can do much
Show concern for unbelieving mates
to affect the heart of an unbelieving family
member. A husband in Nigeria who
accepted the truth 13 years after his wife
did states: “While I was traveling with
a Witness, his vehicle broke down. He
sought out fellow Witnesses in a neighboring
village, and they gave us accommodations
for the night. They cared
for us as if we had known them from
childhood. Right away, I felt the Christian
love that my wife had always spoken
about.” In England, a wife who came
into the truth 18 years after her husband
did recalls: “The Witnesses invited both
of us for meals. I always felt welcome.”*
Says a husband in the same land who
eventually became a Witness: “Brothers
and sisters would visit us, or we were invited
to their homes, and I found that
they had a caring attitude. This was especially
noticeable when I was in the
hospital and many came to visit me.”
Can you find ways to show similar interest
in unbelieving family members?
*Eating with unbelievers is not forbidden in the
Scriptures.—1 Cor. 10:27.
Just don’t invite them to a picnic or to your home (see quote above) How was it that he a non-jw was invited along with his wife? Weren’t they afraid of being “corrupted”?
COMMENTS
Who could he have called in his own congregation? How many calls would he have to make before finding someone? We visited a congregation in the Midwest on a trip, no one talked to us….you could see that despite our appropriate dress and having the proper books, we were viewed suspiciously. The next year we visited again and were ignored again. Finally the third year, a meek little sister came up to us and we had a nice conversation but not a single elder. I found out later that that congregation was well-known for that behavior and that 3 of the elders were ex-bethelites and regular speakers at the conventions.
As to hospital visits, I live in a city with 4 major hospitals and 4 minor ones on the outskirts. Who visits, well they have some assigned to making visits, remember they get to count their time. This is doled out to retired elders who are pioneers and female pioneers (to call on women only). I remember one elder refusing to visit a fellow elder in the hospital because he didn’t like hospitals. And this was his friend. Fortunately, someone else put their love in action.
How many find time to visit the spiritually ill in the congregation; people who are already baptized?
15, 16. What can help a believer to maintain
happiness when others in the family remain
unbelievers?
15 Of course, not all unbelieving
spouses, children, parents, or other relatives
embrace true worship, even after
years of faithful conduct and tactful witnessing
on the part of the believer. Some
remain indifferent or become unrelenting
opposers. (Matt. 10:35-37) When
Christians display godly traits, however,
this can have a very good effect. A former
unbelieving husband states: “When
the believing mate starts to let those
lovely qualities shine, you do not know
what is going on in the unbeliever’s
mind and heart. So don’t ever give up on
your unbelieving mate.”
COMMENTS
Yes, all non-jws are participating in false worship, controlled by the devil; but not jws. What about jws, including elders, that are indifferent to what the bible says; putting what the WTS says ahead of it?
So the believing mate was not showing those lovely qualities before; how did they ever qualify for baptism then? How did the elders and the holy spirit miss seeing that?
16 Even if a family member remains
an unbeliever, happiness is possible for
the believer. Although her husband has
not responded to the Kingdom message
after 21 years of effort on her part,
one sister says: “I am able to maintain
my joy by striving to please Jehovah, by
maintaining my loyalty to him, and by
working to strengthen my spirituality.
Immersing myself in spiritual activities
—personal study, meeting attendance,
the field ministry, and helping others in
the congregation—has drawn me closer
to Jehovah and has safeguarded my
heart.”—Prov. 4:23.
COMMENTS
So it is difficult to be married to a non-jw that is loving, helpful, carrying, supportive, not hitting you but it is better to be married to a jw who goes through the motions, but is a screamer, views the spouse as less valuable, can’t hold a job, etc.?
Spiritual activities = personal study = bible study or WTS publications?
DO NOT GIVE UP!
17, 18. How can a Christian remain hopeful
even in a religiously divided household?
17 If you are a faithful Christian living
in a religiously divided household,
do not give up. Remember that “Jehovah
will not desert his people for the sake
of his great name.” (1 Sam. 12:22) He
is with you as long as you cling to him.
(Read 2 Chronicles 15:2.) So “take exquisite
delight in Jehovah.” Indeed, “roll
upon Jehovah your way, and rely upon
him.” (Ps. 37:4, 5) “Persevere in prayer,”
and have faith that our loving heavenly
Father can help you to endure hardships
of all kinds.—Rom. 12:12.
COMMENTS
Faithful Christian = only jws
His people = this is talking about Israelites and at best spiritual Israelites (only 11,000+ of over 7 million jws)
Does Jesus ever help us?
(Hebrews 2:17,18)17 Consequently he was obliged to become like his “brothers” in all respects, that he might become a merciful and faithful high priest in things pertaining to God, in order to offer propitiatory sacrifice for the sins of the people. 18 For in that he himself has suffered when being put to the test, he is able to come to the aid of those who are being put to the test.
18 Petition Jehovah for his holy spirit
to help you promote peace in the home.
(Heb. 12:14) Yes, it is possible to foster
peaceful conditions that may eventually
touch the heart of unbelieving family
members. You will experience happiness
and peace of heart and mind as you
“do all things for God’s glory.” (1 Cor.
10:31) In these endeavors, how heartening
it is to know that you have the loving
support of your brothers and sisters in
the Christian congregation!
COMMENTS
In my house my parents fought almost every day. My mother knew it would make things worse but…….. It was hard as a child to try and convince my father we “had the truth” when it wasn’t being applied at home.
And we definitely did not have the “loving support” of the people at the KH….but were viewed with suspicion as were 6 other families “divided” religiously in my congregation. Imagine finding out that a witness couple had over a sister and her non-jw, unbelieving husband for dinner, and after 10 years in that congregation, you had never seen the inside of their home.
CONCLUDING COMMENTS
Next week, HELP PEOPLE TO AWAKE FROM SLEEP. Ironic, as jws sleep on not knowing and not wanting to know the past and the present of the WTS who would rather believe a lie than loosen their grasp on “eternal life on a paradise earth surrounded by resurrected family.” And who also wish for the end to come, which would mean the eternal death of over 7 billion non-jws, men, women, children, babies, even babies still in the womb, all without any hope of a resurrection per the WTS.
Love, Blondie