Comments You Will Not Hear at the 07-15-2012 WT Study (MAY 15, 2012, pages 8-12)(STRAINED MARRIAGE)
Review comments will be headed by COMMENTS
WT material from today's WT will be in black
w = Watchtower
g = Awake
jv = Proclaimers book
EXCELLENT GENERAL WEBSITE : www.jwfacts.com
Bible translations www.biblegateway.com/cgi-bin/bible
WT publications www.strictlygenteel.co.uk
WT child abuse www.silentlambs.org
Blood issue www.ajwrb.org
United Nations http://www.randytv.com/secret/unitednations.htm
Also posted on
http://exjehovahswitnessforum.yuku.com
http://www.jwsupportforum.com/index.php
http://www.jehovahswitnessrecovery.com/
TAKE A POSITIVE VIEW
OF A STRAINED MARRIAGE
“To the married people
I give instructions,
yet not I but the Lord.”
—1 COR. 7:10.
OPENING PICTURE: BLACK MAN AND WIFE IN NATIVE COSTUME; WOULD THE ELDERS ALLOW THEM TO WEAR THAT TO THE KH?
OPENING COMMENTS
I can say that out of my generation of pre-1975 married jws, over 50% are now on their 2 nd marriage. I grew up in a “divided household” and I see jw women leaving in droves, not staying the 25 years my mother did. I can remember the elders telling my mother that if she were a “better” wife her problems with my father would go away. And don’t believe the WTS here when they say it is your decision.
START OF ARTICLE
CAN YOU EXPLAIN?
In what sense does God yoke
marriage mates together?
How can elders help Christians
who have marital problems?
How should we view marriage?
START OF ARTICLE
1. How do Christians view marriage, and why?
WHEN Christians get married, they make a
vow before God—a responsibility not to
be taken lightly. (Eccl. 5:4-6) In the sense
that he is the Originator of the marital arrangement,
Jehovah has “yoked together” those united in wedlock.
(Mark 10:9) This yoke exists in God’s sight regardless
of the laws that sanctioned the wedding.
Servants of Jehovah should view marriage as a binding
arrangement whether they were his worshippers
at the time of their wedding or not.
COMMENTS
Christians = only jws
Baptism is a vow, marriage is a vow, yet getting married at 10 as a jw is severely frowned on by the WTS, but not baptism. Is marriage a lesser vow then?
So if non-jws get married they are not responsible to the god of the bible, their marriage is not valid? Do non-jws have to get remarried when becoming jws as they are required to get rebaptized?
Servants of Jehovah = only jws
The religious aspect of marriage was more important to the WTS in that they allowed jws to marry and remarry that did not fulfill the laws of the country they lived in, those that did not allow divorce.
***True Peace book tp chap.13p.148par.16***
What if the laws of a land do not allow any divorce, even on the ground of sexual immorality? An innocent mate in such a case might be able to obtain a divorce in a country where divorce is permitted. Circumstances, of course, may not allow for this. But some form of legal separation may be available in one’s own country and could be sought. Whatever the case, the innocent mate could separate from the guilty one and present definite proof of Scriptural ground for divorce to the overseers in the local congregation of Jehovah’s Witnesses. What if that person were later to decide to take another mate? The congregation would not act to remove him as an adulterer if he provided the congregation with a written statement containing a vow of faithfulness to the present mate and an agreement to obtain a legal marriage certificate if the former marriage should be dissolved either legally or by death. Nevertheless, the individual would have to face whatever consequences might result as far as the world outside the congregation is concerned. For the world does not generally recognize that God’s law is superior to human laws and that human laws have only relative authority.—Compare Acts 5:29.
*** w77 3/15 pp.183-184 par.31***
“I, ......., do here declare that I have accepted .......... as my mate in marital relationship; that I have done all within my ability to obtain legal recognition of this relationship by the proper public authorities and that it is because of having been unable to do so that I therefore make this declaration pledging faithfulness in this marital relationship. I recognize this relationship as a binding tie before Jehovah God and before all persons, to be held to and honored in full accord with the principles of God’s Word. I will continue to seek the means to obtain legal recognition of this relationship by the civil authorities and if at any future time a change in circumstances makes this possible I promise to legalize this union.
“Signed this .......... day of ........., 19..... Witnesses to my signing: .....................................”
2. What questions will be considered in this article?
2 A successful marriage can result in great happiness.
But what can be done if the marital bond
is strained? Can a weakened marriage be strengthened?
What help is there for those whose marital
peace is threatened?
COMMENTS
Amazingly, the marriages I saw that were most likely to be strained and end in divorce were elders…in fact, 4 in the last 2 years in the last congregation I attended. Hmmmm…………so do they teach by example?
WILL IT BE A JOY OR A HEARTACHE?
3, 4. What may happen if a person makes an unwise decision
when choosing a marriage mate?
3 When a Christian’s marriage succeeds, it is a
joy and brings honor to Jehovah. If it fails, it is a
heartache at best. An unmarried Christian who is
contemplating wedlock is in a position to get marriage
off to a fine start by following God’s guidance.
On the other hand, a person who makes an unwise
decision when choosing a husband or a wife may
experience dissatisfaction and grief. For instance,
some youths begin dating when they are not ready
for the responsibilities associated with married life.
Certain individuals find a prospective mate on the
Internet and rush into what proves to be a very unhappy
marriage. Others commit a serious sin during
courtship and marry anyway, but
they may begin their married life with
little respect for each other.
COMMENTS
Christian’s marriage = only jws
God’s guidance or WTS guidance? Remember this is the same god that allowed polygamy. And did not allow women to divorce their mates but allowed men to divorce wives for reasons other than adultery.
Unwise decision = marry a non-jw
Youths begin dating…not ready for married life---what age, 9, 13, 15? But old enough to get baptized?
*** w01 5/15 p.19 par.11***
Knowing when we are ready to marry is vital. Since this varies from one individual to another, the Scriptures do not stipulate an age. They do show, however, that it is better to wait until we are “past the bloom of youth,” when strong sexual impulses can distort good judgment. (1 Corinthians 7:36) “When I saw my friends dating and marrying, many in their teen years, it was at times difficult to apply this counsel,” says Michelle. “But I realized that the counsel is from Jehovah, and he tells us only what is for our benefit.
4 Some Christians do not marry “only
in the Lord” and suffer the often painful
consequences of a religiously divided
household. (1 Cor. 7:39) If that is
your experience, pray for God’s forgiveness
and help. He does not remove the
effects of a person’s past errors, but he
does assist repentant ones to cope with
trials. (Ps. 130:1-4) Put your heart into
pleasing him now and forever, and ‘the
joy of Jehovah will be your stronghold.’
—Neh. 8:10.
COMMENTS
So did Esther suffer when she married the Persian (non-Israelite) king; a marriage her family head, Mordecai, encouraged?
Are they suggesting that Naomi’s sons died because they married non-Israelite women…or that they were unhappy….or they died childless because of god’s intervention?
Most women married to non-jws that I knew were married to them before they became jws…should they think that they need God’s forgiveness; should they leave their spouses as Ezra encouraged the Israelite men to do, as well as send away the children?
Who does have sin every day and need God’s forgiveness (per Christian thought)?
And don’t forget Deut. 21:10-14 allowing marriage to unbelievers as opposed to Deut. 7:3,4 which talked only of Canaanites.
WHEN MARITAL BONDS
ARE THREATENED
5. Regarding an unhappy marriage, what kind
of thinking should be avoided?
5 Those who experience heartache in
the marital relationship may wonder: ‘Is
my unhappy marriage really worth saving?
If only I could turn back the clock
and begin again with another marriage
mate!’ They may dream of breaking the
bond—‘Oh, to be free again! Why not get
a divorce? Even if I cannot get a Scriptural
divorce, why not separate and enjoy
life again?’ Instead of thinking in those
terms or fantasizing about what might
have been, Christians should make the
best of their current state by seeking
God’s guidance and following it.
COMMENTS
What about abusive marriages? Or ones where one mate has reduced the family to poverty?
At one point the WTS would not allow divorce on the grounds of homosexuality or bestiality but then reversed its edicts a few years later. If you had divorced before the reversal and remarried, been df’d, the df’ing would not be reversed.
At one point, the congregation I was in had 3 separations, both jws and 2 elders…perhaps because they knew you could not be df’d for getting a separation.
6. Explain what Jesus said, as recorded at Matthew
19:9.
6 If a Christian were to get a divorce,
he or she may or may not be Scripturally
free to get married again. Jesus said:
“Whoever divorces his wife, except on
the ground of fornication, and marries
another commits adultery.” (Matt.
19:9) Here, “fornication” includes adultery
and other serious sexual sins. It
is vital to weigh prayerfully any thought
of divorce when neither mate has been
guilty of sexual immorality.
COMMENTS
But one mate has to PROVE to the elders satisfaction that the grounds are scriptural. They have the power to interpret what is scriptural.
*** tp chap.13 p.147 par.14***
This is emphasized by the fact that he acknowledges only one proper basis for divorce. Jesus showed what this is: “Whoever divorces his wife, except on the ground of fornication [por·nei′a], and marries another commits adultery.” (Matthew 19:9; 5:32) Por·nei′a, as we have seen, refers to sexual relations outside of marriage, whether natural or unnatural.
----------what are sexual relations though, mutual masturbation, touching a breast (female but not male?), phone sex with a living person while masturbating? Does this clear it up? Some people think that the only purpose God had for sex was procreation.
*** w11 11/1 p.5***
Por·nei′a also refers to other acts that deviate from God’s original purpose in creating the human sexual organs, such as adultery, homosexuality, and bestiality.
7. What may observers think if a Christian
marriage fails?
7 A failed marriage may cast doubt
on one’s spiritual state. The apostle Paul
raised this serious question: “If indeed
any man does not know how to preside
over his own household, how will
he take care of God’s congregation?”
(1 Tim. 3:5) In fact, when both mates
profess to be Christians and yet their
marriage fails, observers may think that
such individuals do not really practice
what they preach.—Rom. 2:21-24.
COMMENTS
So who will doubt a person’s spiritual state; is it automatic that both mates are responsible? But then the WTS is only worried about the man, the one who presides.
So why would jws judge them without the facts, thinking they do not practice what they preach. What about David, he committed adultery, killed the woman’s husband to hide his capital sin under the Law, did the nation of Israel think he did not practice what he preached? Did god judge him, saving him from execution under the Law code?
8. What must be wrong if Christian mates decide
to part?
8 When baptized marriage mates are
planning to separate or to divorce each
other on unscriptural grounds, something
surely is spiritually wrong in their
life. Scriptural principles are apparently
not being applied by one partner or perhaps
by both partners. If they were truly
‘trusting in Jehovah with all their heart,’
there would be little reason for believing
that they could not avoid a failed
marriage.—Read Proverbs 3:5, 6.
COMMENTS
Unless the following occurs….but a means to separate or divorce, but not scripturally, not able to remarry.
Where is the imperfection clause elders apply in their cases, that “scriptural principles are apparently not being applied.”
*** w88 11/1 p.22 par.11***
Extreme physical abuse is another basis for separation.
Absolute endangerment of spirituality also provides a basis for separation.
Willful nonsupport is one basis for separation.
PICTURE: (Young white couple, she’s being a good wife topping off his coffee as he reads the paper…not even a WT magazine and she has bible and bookbag in hand on the way to the KH. So a strained marriage is going to be helped by pouring coffee?)
Jehovah blesses Christian mates who make
efforts to strengthen a strained marriage
9. How have some Christians been rewarded
for their patient efforts in connection with marriage?
9 Many marriages that seemed to
be headed for failure have in time
turned out to be very successful. Christians
who refuse to give up quickly on
a difficult marriage often enjoy a fine
reward. Consider what can happen
in a religiously divided household. The
apostle Peter wrote: “You wives, be in
subjection to your own husbands, in order
that, if any are not obedient to the
word, they may be won without a word
through the conduct of their wives, because
of having been eyewitnesses of
your chaste conduct together with deep
respect.” (1 Pet. 3:1, 2) Yes, because of
his mate’s fine conduct, an unbeliever
may embrace the true faith! Such
a saved marriage honors God and can
be a great blessing for the husband,
the wife, and any children they may
have.
COMMENTS
So if they seemed headed for failure …was doubt cast on their spiritual state that scriptural principles were apparently not being applied?
Won without a word…so is the wife responsible for her husband’s abuse because she is not a good enough wife?
So why is the unbeliever always cast as the husband; are there no jw husbands with non-jw wives?
10, 11. What unexpected problems may arise
in a marriage, but of what may a Christian be
certain?
10 With a desire to please Jehovah,
most single Christians choose dedicated
fellow believers as marriage mates.
Even then, however, circumstances may
take an unexpected turn. On rare occasions,
for example, a mate may develop
serious emotional problems. Or some
time after the wedding, a spouse may
become an inactive publisher. To illustrate:
Linda,* a zealous Christian and a
devoted mother, watched helplessly as
her baptized husband unrepentantly
embarked on an unscriptural path and
was disfellowshipped. What should a
Christian do if his or her marriage bond
seems hopelessly frayed for such a reason?
*Names have been changed.
COMMENTS
So mental illness and being an inactive jw even being df’d are not grounds for the other jw mate to divorce. But how many on JWN were divorced by their mates for WTS nonscriptural grounds.
11 ‘Must I keep on trying to save my
marriage no matter what happens?’ you
might ask. Nobody can or should make
such a decision for you. Yet, there are
sound reasons for not giving up on a
marital bond that is weakening. The
godly man or woman who endures the
trials of a difficult marriage for the sake
of conscience is precious to God. (Read
1 Peter 2:19, 20.) By means of his Word
and spirit, Jehovah will help a Christian
who makes earnest efforts to strengthen
a strained marriage.
COMMENTS
While the WTS says “nobody can or should make such a decision for you” “must I keep on trying to save my marriage no matter what happens” on what basis can other jws:
So if they seemed headed for failure …was doubt cast on their spiritual state that scriptural principles were apparently not being applied?
THEY ARE READY TO ASSIST
12. How will the elders view us if we seek their
help?
12 If you face marital problems, do
not hesitate to seek the spiritual assistance
of mature Christians. The elders
serve as shepherds of the flock and will
gladly direct attention to the inspired
Christians who do not give up quickly on a
strained marriage often enjoy a fine reward
counsel found in the Scriptures. (Acts
20:28; Jas. 5:14, 15) Do not conclude
that you and your mate will lose the respect
of the elders if you seek spiritual
assistance and discuss a serious marital
problem with them. Their loving regard
for you will increase as they see that you
earnestly desire to please God.
COMMENTS
Mature Christians – the WTS does send women to older female jws
How successful are the marriages of these elders; are they already on their 2 nd wife or in some cases 3 rd wife?
Lose respect – but the WTS says they could be viewed that their spiritual state is weak and they apparently are not applying scriptures.
13. What counsel is found at 1 Corinthians 7:
10-16?
13 When asked for help by Christians
living in religiously divided households,
elders refer to such counsel as that of
Paul, who wrote: “To the married people
I give instructions, yet not I but the
Lord, that a wife should not depart from
her husband; but if she should actually
depart, let her remain unmarried or else
make up again with her husband; and a
husband should not leave his wife. . . .
For, wife, how do you know but that
you will save your husband? Or, husband,
how do you know but that you
will save your wife?” (1 Cor. 7:10-16)
What a blessing it is when an unbelieving
mate is won over to true worship!
COMMENTS
So a wife should stay but are husbands told to stay by elders?
14, 15. When might a Christian spouse consider
actually departing, but why is prayerful
and honest consideration important?
14 Under what circumstances might a
Christian wife “actually depart”? Some
have chosen to separate because of a
mate’s willful nonsupport. Others have
done so because of extreme physical
abuse or the absolute endangerment of
a Christian’s spirituality.
COMMENTS
But who judges that the husband is guilty of this, the wife, the elders? Does it matter whether the husband is a jw or not?
15 Whether to depart or not is a personal
decision. However, the baptized
mate ought to give this matter prayerful
and honest consideration. For example,
has the unbeliever been totally responsible
for the endangerment of spirituality,
or has the Christian been negligent
about Bible study, inconsistent in meeting
attendance, and irregular in the
ministry?
COMMENTS
Is it a personal decision, or will their spirituality be called into question?
So how do the elders assign blame to the wife….since they are not under the roof to see how the non-jw husband acts?
16. What should restrain Christians from making
hasty decisions regarding divorce?
16 The fact that we treasure our relationship
with God and are grateful for
his gift of marriage ought to restrain us
from making hasty decisions regarding
divorce. As servants of Jehovah, we are
concerned about the sanctification of
his holy name. Surely, then, we would
never scheme to get out of one marriage
while our heart is planning on another
marriage.—Jer. 17:9; Mal. 2:13-16.
COMMENTS
So what is “hasty”? Who decides, the elders; it is one year, 2 years, 5 years….?
Servants of Jehovah = jws, but why not Christians
(Acts 11:26) . . .it was first in Antioch that the disciples were by divine providence called Christians.
Sounds like too many jws are manipulating the WTS rules re divorce to marry a new spouse. Remember though that Ezra told the Israelite men to send away their non-jw wives and children (!).
17. Under what circumstances could it be said
that God has called married Christians to
peace?
17 A Christian who is married to an
unbeliever should earnestly endeavor to
keep the marriage bond intact. Yet, a
Christian need not feel guilty if, despite
the Christian’s sincere effort to preserve
the union, an unbelieving mate refuses
to remain with the believer. “If the
unbelieving one proceeds to depart, let
him depart,” wrote Paul. “A brother or a
sister is not in servitude under such circumstances,
but God has called you to
peace.”—1 Cor. 7:15.*
*See “Keep Yourselves in God’s Love,” pages 219-
221; The Watchtower of November 1, 1988, pages 26-
27; September 15, 1975, page 575.
COMMENTS
So the unbeliever can leave but not the abused jw wife? Who decides and how do they decide the effort is “sincere.”
PICTURE: (Same woman outside KH with a couple talking to her)
The Christian congregation can be a source of
comfort and spiritual assistance
HOPE IN JEHOVAH
18. Even if it is not possible to save a marriage,
what good may result from efforts to do so?
18 When dealing with any marital
problem, look to Jehovah for courage
and always hope in him. (Read Psalm
27:14.) Consider Linda, who was mentioned
earlier. Her marriage eventually
ended in divorce, although she had
put many years of effort into trying to
save it. Does she feel that she wasted
her time? “Not at all,” she says. “My
efforts gave a good witness to onlookers.
I have a clear conscience. Best of all,
those years helped our daughter to stay
solidly in the truth. She grew up to be a
zealous, dedicated Witness of Jehovah.”
COMMENTS
Put MANY years of effort…so what happened to make her decide to stop trying?
Good witness – or a holy pretense?
Did it teach her daughter rather to stay in an abusive marriage?
But did she grow up to be a Christian?
19. What may happen if efforts are made to
save a marriage?
19 A Christian woman named Marilyn
is glad that she trusted in God and
put forth extra effort to save her marriage.
“I was tempted to separate from
my husband because of financial nonsupport
and spiritual endangerment,”
she says. “Yet, my husband served as
an elder before he got involved in some
unwise business arrangements. He began
missing meetings, and we simply
stopped communicating. A terrorist attack
in our city frightened me so much
that I withdrew into a shell. Then I realized
that I too was at fault. We started
communicating again, resumed our
family study, and became regular at
meetings. The elders were kind and
very helpful. Our marriage blossomed
anew. In time, my husband again qualified
for congregation privileges. It was a
hard lesson with a happy outcome.”
COMMENTS
So no jw husbands as examples of staying in a bad marriage?
What a happy ending…unwise business arrangements…missing meetings…she’s lucky he wasn’t like Christian Longo.
So the elders hadn’t judged them spiritually weak?
20, 21. With respect to marriage, what should
we be resolved to do?
20 Whether we are single or married,
let us always act courageously and hope
in Jehovah. If we are encountering marital
difficulties, we should earnestly
seek to resolve them, remembering that
those united in wedlock are “no longer
two, but one flesh.” (Matt. 19:6) And let
us bear in mind that if we persevere in
a divided household despite hardships,
we may experience the joy of winning a
mate over to true worship.
COMMENTS
How many jw men did you know had non-jw wives?
21 Regardless of our circumstances,
may we be resolved to walk circumspectly
in order to have a fine testimony
from observers outside the congregation.
If our marriage is threatened, let us
pray intensely, scrutinize our motives
honestly, consider the Scriptures carefully,
and seek the spiritual assistance
of the elders. Above all, may we be determined
to please Jehovah God in all
things and show real appreciation for
his wonderful gift of marriage.
COMMENTS
So how much abuse should a jw spouse submit to be a “fine testimony”?
Who will be scrutinizing our motives?
A failed marriage may cast doubt
on one’s spiritual state.
When baptized marriage mates are
planning to separate or to divorce each
other on unscriptural grounds, something
surely is spiritually wrong in their
life. Scriptural principles are apparently
not being applied by one partner or perhaps
by both partners.
CONCLUDING COMMENTS
Remember that Charles Taze Russell’s marriage did not go well. J.F. Rutherford lived separately from his wife for years until his death. He lived in California at Beth Sarim while his wife lived in California just miles away from him under a separate roof. No mention was made of her in the publications post 1950 until 1993, 31 years after her death. I wonder if some thought he was not presiding well over his household?
*** jv chap.7 p.76***
Brother Rutherford had a severe case of pneumonia after his release from unjust imprisonment in 1919. Thereafter, he had only one good lung. In the 1920’s, under a doctor’s treatment, he went to San Diego, California, and the doctor urged him to spend as much time as possible there. From 1929 on, Brother Rutherford spent the winters working at a San Diego residence he had named Beth-Sarim.
*** jv chap. 7 p.89***
Brother Rutherford was survived by his wife, Mary, and their son, Malcolm. Because Sister Rutherford had poor health and found the winters in New York (where the Watch Tower Society’s headquarters were located) difficult to endure, she and Malcolm had been residing in southern California, where the climate was better for her health. Sister Rutherford died December 17, 1962, at the age of 93. Notice of her death, appearing in the Monrovia, California, DailyNews-Post, stated: “Until poor health confined her to her home, she took an active part in the ministerial work of Jehovah’s Witnesses.”