Resurrection,Did He or didn't He?

by FrankRaven 14 Replies latest jw friends

  • FrankRaven
    FrankRaven

    According to all the gospels Christ rose,resurrection,from the dead.Yet the WatchTower says Christ did,as a spirit creature.And his real body turned to gasses.Turning to gasses is not a resurrection.1John 43:3 says,"and every spirit does not confess that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh,(John1:14)is not of God.And this is the spirit of the AntiChrist,which you have heard was coming,and is now already in the world."2John 7,"For many deceivers have gone out into the world who do not confess Jesus Christ as coming in the flesh.This is the deceiver and the antichrist."1John 2:22,"Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ?He is the antichrist who denies the Father and the Son."
    So if one denies the Son,denies the Father.And how does the WatchTower baptize?Let's see.......
    In the name of the Father,and of the Son,and of Jehovah God's Spirit filled organization.
    A Spirit filled organization?Another Spirit besides the Holy Spirit?
    The spirit of the deceivers are called the antichrist.Now it's clear to me that I know the antichrist.Do you?

    RevFrank

  • AGuest
    AGuest

    Peace to you.

    You are talking of when my Lord lived on earth... in the flesh. HOWEVER... regarding his RESURRECTION...

    "It is sown (buried) a PHYSICAL body; it is raised up (resurrected)... a SPIRIT body."

    Read your Bible, dear Rev Frank. Please. In fact, read John 5:39, 40... and hear what is said there... to get the sense of it.

    A slave of Christ,

    SJ

  • FrankRaven
    FrankRaven

    He rose the same as he died....Where in scripture does it say he rose in a spirit form?
    Luke 24:39,says,"Behold My hands and My feet,that it is I Myself.Handle me and see for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see I have."

    RevFrank

  • D8TA
    D8TA

    RevDav,

    I too, have always questioned the WTBTS view on Jesus's ressurection. Better yet, (I presume here since it's the exact wording in the NWT), you use the WTBTS translation of the bible
    to bring up a very good point.

    How did the ever-so-"spirited directed ones" conclude that Jesus rose in spirit and not the flesh? When it's plain as day, (even in their own bible) it's right there?

    Butthen again, coincidentally, only the "annointed" ones can have Jesus as a mediator. Only the Governing Body and few of their "associates" are "spirit-directed". How convienant. How VERY convienant for them to be in such positions.

    In essence: A fellow human being telling other people that they are "spirit-directed" and/or "annointed" and others are not. And they convienantly happen to be the only ones "publishing" material to their flock, telling them what "Jehovah" really means. That the rest of the "flock" are in need of this guidance from the "spirit directed" and/or "annointed". Humans can never be wrong, can they?
    If they are wrong, they just apply "new light" to the situation...of course this is the "spirited directed" and/or "annointed" point of view of scipture. Again, how darn convienant. And of course, since the rest of christianity is under the influence of Satan, this means that they are right. But, humans are perfect? Right? Again...how convienant that this point of view comes from these "spirit directed" and/or "annointed" ones.

    I just guess the rest of us just don't know any better. (sigh)

    *wink wink*

    D8TA

  • AGuest
    AGuest

    Dear Rev... may you have peace.

    If you recall, when the women went to tomb to conclude the preparation of my Lord's body of EARTHLY FLESH, there was no body. Why? It had been 'changed', transfigured into a spirit body, which my Lord demonstrated for Peter, John and James some time before.

    That is why, when the women and others SAW him, they did not RECOGNIZE him, for it was NOT the fleshly vessel that they knew, but others: he simply transferred his spirit INTO such 'vessels'... such clay 'pots', if you will... so as to be manifest to them.

    The last fleshly vessel that he 'occupied' (okay, possessed, for even a GOOD spirit can possess...), was also 'transfigured', when the disciples witnessed my Lord ascending...

    That is how it works, dear one. The fleshly body is a 'seed', per se, planted in the earth (sowed), and then a NEW body (the spirit one) 'grows'... or is raised up.

    The easiest way to understand this is to view my Father, the Holy One of Israel, JAH OF ARMIES, as He TRULY is... a farmer... or 'cultivator'. He 'sows' or plants seed and entrusts the care of that seed to others pending harvest.

    My Lord, His Son and Christ, JAHESHUA MISCHJAH, then, is the "true vine", the "root of Jesse", "SPROUT!", of which those who 'belong' to him, are branches. The physical body is the 'seed'... sown in the earth, after its 'throwing down' from the SPIRIT realm (to 'hide' it from enemies - "treasure hidden in EARTHEN vessels"). But the TRUE branch, that which is IN my Lord, the Tree of Life, the TRUE vine... is the 'flower', the 'grain'... that is harvested.

    For as my Lord is recorded to have said: "The flesh... is of NO use... at all."

    Again, I bid you peace.

    YOUR servant, and a slave of Christ,

    SJ

  • Undecided
    Undecided

    Hi All,

    This is so typical of all Christain religions, each person, church group has it's own view of what the bible means when it describes some event or teaching. Do you really think God would produce a book to guide mankind that could never be understood? This is why I have abandoned the bible and all religions, they have no better understanding of God than any non religious person.

    Ken P.

  • FrankRaven
    FrankRaven

    JediMember,
    Again I ask,did Jesus say he changed?No and you refuse to read Luke 24:39.No where in the bible,not the NWT,does it say that Christ came back as a spirit creature.To have Him change would not be a resurrection.And if there be no resurrection our faith is naught.And since you believe He came as a ghost there is no God within you as Romans 8:8-10 states.

    RevFrank

  • AGuest
    AGuest

    Dear Rev... peace to you... and are you addressing me ("AGuest")? I believe you are, so permit me to respond. Thank you.

    Again I ask,did Jesus say he changed?
    Actually, he said he would... but he also said that he would say things that not all would understand, for it was not FOR all to understand, yes?

    John 16:7, compare to John 16:13
    John 14:17, compare to Romans 8:9-11
    John 6:63, compare to 1 Corinthians 15:45
    John 6:64 and 16:7, compare to John 14:6
    1 Corinthians 15:42-49, compare to 15:20-23
    2 Corinthians 3:17

    No and you refuse to read Luke 24:39.
    Quite the contrary, I have read it. Now I will explain it:

    When my Lord was put to death in the flesh, that body 'did not see corruption'. Rather than decay, it was 'changed', so that it would not begin decay and thus could enter into the spirit realm, the portion of which is Hades... or the world of the dead. For three days, he went there and preached TO THE SPIRITS there, so that they could put faith in him. Such spirits were those who died during Noah's day and were 'awakened'... but not 'resurrected' (raised up). When he left that place, they returned to 'sleep'.

    When my Lord returned to THIS realm right after, he did what many spirits do... occupied other 'earthen vessels'... physical flesh. That is why those who SAW him, did not immediately RECOGNIZE him... until he SPOKE to them. THEN, they 'recognized' the PERSON in the vessel... their 'eyes'... were 'opened'. It didn't matter what he LOOKED like, but that it indeed was him.

    Because of their LACK OF FAITH, however, my Lord eventually 'put on' a body that his disciples WOULD recognize, with holes, etc., for THEIR benefit. Why? Because, as they demonstrated when the women reported it, and Thomas demonstrated when my Lord was standing before him... THEY LACKED FAITH. Tell me, if YOU died today, and came back in the EXACT SAME BODY... wouldn't YOUR friends and family recognize you? The only way they wouldn't, dear one, is if the body... was DIFFERENT. But once you started to SPEAK to them, they WOULD recognize your VOICE, yes?

    John 10:27

    Okay. Now, my Lord died in the corruptible flesh - and his flesh WAS corruptible (which is WHY Satan tried to TEMPT such flesh) - for it was sinFUL (Romans 8:3)... or full of sin... thus IT DIED... (for sinLESS flesh is perfect: it has NO corruption... or sickness, or sin... or DEATH... IN IT... thus, it CANNOT die!). But he was RAISED UP or resurrected in that which is INCORRUPTIBLE, and THAT was placed in vessels, which again were CHANGED, as 'evidenced'... at his ascension.

    No where in the bible,not the NWT,does it say that Christ came back as a spirit creature.
    Well, okay, not 'came back'. But nowhere does it 'say' he is the Tree of Life... but it is REPEATEDLY implied!

    John 15:1
    Isaiah 11:10
    Revelation 5:5
    Revelation 22:16
    John 14:6
    Genesis 3:22
    John 6:48-58
    Revelation 22:1, 2

    Indeed, it does not SAY that he is the "Tree" of Life, the one from which if ANY eat, they will NOT die, but live forever. And yet, HE said: "He that eats MY flesh and drinks MY blood... will live... FOREVER." Thus, his flesh and blood are the LEAVES of the TREE that is HIM... which is for the 'curing' of the nations, the bringing of them BACK... from death... to life. But... it does not SAY that, does it?

    You see, I, too, used to try and 'discern' what was meant and intended by what is 'written'. Eventually, I was invited to and have learned to listen, instead, to the One about whom such things are written... and who SPEAKS TO US... from the heavens.

    Hebrews 12:25

    Why? Because HE said:

    "To YOU, O mean, I am calling and MY VOICE
    is to the sons of men. O INEXPERIENCED ONES,
    UNDERSTAND shrewdness and you STUPID ones,
    understand the GOOD motive. LISTEN... for
    it is about the FOREMOST things that I
    speak
    , and the opening of MY lips is about
    uprightness (truth).

    "For MY palate in low tones UTTERS TRUTH
    ITSELF; and wickedness (or deceit) is something
    detestable to my lips. ALL the sayings of MY
    mouth... are in rightness (truth). Among them
    there is NOTHING twisted... or crooked. ALL
    of them are straight... TO THE DISCERNING ONE...
    and upright... to the one FINDING... knowledge."

    Proverbs 8:4-9

    What did he mean by this, Rev? That we could rely on ourselves, that we are righteous and discerning, that we could rely on what is written and THINK that we will understand it... or... we can listen to HIM... and HE will tell us what is truth. By means of the spirit of God, holy spirit, which is a GIFT that HE dispenses, WE... can receive the GIFT of that spirit, one of which is 'discerning inspired utterances', or 'knowledge of spirits', a gift I have received.

    As a result of that gift, rather than speaking of my OWN initiative and telling you what I think, I tell you what my Lord tells ME... by means of that gift, through holy spirit... and since it originated NOT with me... but with the TRUTH (John 14:6), what I tell you is truth.

    To have Him change would not be a resurrection.
    That depends. If he is standing there and changes, true. He never died. However, both the flesh AND the spirit can be resurrected, dear one. Although my Lord died 'in the flesh', death did not have a 'hold' on his SPIRIT, as it has on others, and so God 'raised up'... his spirit... and put it in OTHER 'vessels'.

    My Lord indeed came in the flesh, and was killed in such flesh. When he went to Hades, that flesh was changed in order to ENTER Hades. How so? Does not the flesh need food... air... water? Are there such things in Hades? Okay, so he could have gone without food and water for 3 days... but without air? The spirit body, though, does not NEED air, for it has no need to breath oxygen.

    When his spirit was RESURRECTED or raised up from Hades, it was as he had been changed to, so that he was now a raised up SPIRIT. In order to be manifest to his discples, however, that spirit was then placed in various bodies or vessels, that last of which was also 'changed' at his ascension.

    And if there be no resurrection our faith is naught.
    Oh, no, my dear one, my Lord was INDEED resurrected... for death had and has NO hold on him. Had he not been resurrected, he would still be IN Hades, with the SPIRITS of the other 'dead'. Yes?

    And since you believe He came as a ghost there is no God within you as Romans 8:8-10 states.
    Actually, these verses further prove my point. For, as my Lord himself SAID:

    "The flesh... is of NO use... at all."

    So, indeed, when resurrected in the SPIRIT, my Lord again put on FLESH, flesh which was of no use... and was subsequently 'changed'... again... as it was before, in order to 'enter' into the spirit realm... a place that flesh... with its blood... cannot enter.

    I can only offer to you Paul's words at 1 Corinthians 15:42-57... and no, I don't 'follow' Paul, but he speaks truth here, which explains that those who belong to the Christ and have died are resurrected in INCORRUPTIBLE... or spirit... bodies. Why would such ones receive something my Lord did not? Does it not occur with him FIRST... and then with us? And such ones are resurrected, as spirits, at the same time that those who have NOT died... are changed... INTO spirits.

    Thus, those who take part in the first resurrection, because they are not judged (for those in union with Christ have no judgment), are immediately granted white robes... or spirit bodies... as was my Lord. His 'befouled garment' was removed, and he was given a 'clean turban'. For when HE died, he paid the 'wage' of sin... for his blood... was righteous. We, unfortunately, cannot do the same thing, for our blood, can atone for nothing, including our own sins. His blood, however, ALSO atoned for those who belong to him, so that they CAN be 'raised'... in incorruption... like he was. Their sins are atoned for and they can receive a white... or clean... 'robe'... or body, the SPIRIT one.

    Again, I bid you peace.

    YOUR servant and a slave of Christ,

    SJ

  • FrankRaven
    FrankRaven

    JediMember:According to you,you must be a Witness.When Christ walked the Earth,he spoke to simple people.The Scribes and Paraseese where the ones who had lengthly talks on the law.And as you know Christ accused them of forgeting the Spirit of the Law..and not knowing the law and what it meant.
    Simple people....the words of the Bible say it simplly.Easy to know.Christ knew that Him speaking in parables where for those who had to do a little work..others wouldn't even try.
    Parables were also for those who had pride,and thought they knew all.
    As in Luke 24:39 is simple.
    The WatchTower tells that no one can study the bible alone.This is a lie.Or did Christ lie?He said he wasn't a spirit in Luke 24:39.But you disagree..So to you Christ is a lier and the WatchTower is truth.
    So how many times are you waving to and fro?If God be God,then follow Him.Or if Baal is god,follow him.(WatchTower)

    RevFrank

  • AGuest
    AGuest

    Dearest Rev Frank... may you have peace...

    and may I say that you are correct: when my Lord appeared to his disciples, he appeared in flesh. And I explained this, as he permitted me. My Lord now directs me to ask YOU... if his flesh was the flesh that YOU believe it was, that which he possessed BEFORE being put to death, rather than that which can 'change'...

    how is that his 'beloved', John, who was gifted with revelation, stated that 'although the doors were LOCKED... JahEshua came... and stood in their midst'...?

    You see, dear one, the flesh he had BEFORE he was 'put to death' had death and corruption IN it. Since it was sinFUL... or full of sin... sin being corruption (sickness and aging), it could hold in IT death. Thus, that vessel died on the stake. The flesh he put on AFTERWARD, however, did not: it was 'perfect'... having in it NO death or corruption. Thus, it could not only enter through locked doors of THIS world... it could enter into the 'locked' gates... of the kingdom... into which flesh... with its BLOOD... can NOT enter.

    And it was such flesh... that ascended TO that kingdom... WITHOUT dying. It was flesh that was 'changed'. His SPIRIT, however, was NOT left in Sheol, but was resurrected to take ON such flesh.

    I, myself, SJ, have spoken it to you, just as I have heard it from my Lord, the Son of the Holy One of Israel, the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, JAH OF ARMIES, whose Son IS... JAHESHUA MISCHAJAH.

    Oh, BTW... I am not a Jehovah's Witness nor a follower or adherent to the WTBTS. Ask ANYONE here.

    Again, I bid you peace.

    YOUR servant, and a slave of Christ,

    SJ

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit