Tec.... in all the years I have known you , I have never once seen you accept a piece of evidence contrary to your world view lying down, you fight it to the bitter end. This I like in people. As long as they hold such high standards of scrutiny of evidence in all areas of their life.
With regard to MT, it isnt that complicated. We know the Catholic church teaches suffering, all christians do " Persevere! Endure! Better to suffer with Christ than rejoice without Him!" (Catholic Online)
The woman had her own ideas on suffeing and its reward. We believe she was wrong and wrong to enforce them on those most in need. I dont think you would disagree, so whats to argue?
I find it odd that now I am not a 'believer' this is the first time in years I have contemplated 'suffering'. What an odd perspective on the world. What is suffering? A person with a chronic disease is suffering, but they are alive! A man without a job is suffering as may his family be, but he is not looking for sources of income on a pile of trash in Africa as many, many people will be as we speak! We so easily define suffering as something that others would wish for!
Very few people actually really suffer. I work in hospitals all day and though I see people struggle, they do so in appreciation of life and they by-enlarge want to extend that life. If it was such a life of suffering, then who would want that?
It is such a melancholic curse of religion to label life as a challenge, a storm of struggles and fights for which we need a church and saviour to guide us through. It is nonsense! The tribes of the amazon, yet to meet a bible or a Quaran, eat sleep, poop, have sex and if they can find the right leaves, have a boogie every now and then! The biggest source of suffering today ?????? Religious texts !
As a JW I felt a victim to an 'unforseen occurence'. A car accident that physically pains me to this day. Now it is just an aggrevation that I strive to live with as I recognise the value of each day. I am not suffering, I am fortunate to be alive!
Snare.
Ok back to MT.... I am glad she was not my nurse. (pulled the topic back at the end!)