mav,
My wife has made every effort to keep things peaceable. Instead of them reciprocating love, they give her grief, guilt trips, and shame. They are manipulative, uncaring people (that is my opinion).
My wife still loves them....but it is obvious that they don't love her.
I've seen families exist in happiness when someone is shunned. The family just doesn't participate in the shunning.
Her family shuns to the point of meanness. You obviously have no conscience, to put the blame on my wife.
Their attitude is 'my way or no way'. That is the way the WTBTS teaches, from the simplest doctrine on up. The result is an religiously emotional child who can barely suckle at the breast of life because of fear of 'sinning'. In the end, life itself is sacrificed, and yes, this includes family.
If there's anything taught in the bible is that family is very important. As long as the bible's moral code is upheld, then no Witness should shun another, even if they do consider them sinners.
Take into account your own feelings on the issue. Perhaps when you became a witness your family shunned you from the other side. Do you feel it's sweet revenge to shun other people when they choose NOT to be a witness? Sometimes it feels that way to me.
I've seen families destroyed by the shunning doctrine, people's lives destroyed. They commit some small sin, and yet their life is ruined, not because of the consequences of the sin, but because of the harshness of the punishment.
Would you demand capital punishment for someone stealing a pie cooling on a window?
That is what I have always seen it as.
Shunning for molestation, murder, or other crimes that ARE severe could make sense, especially if the person is dangerous (this is the only situation where I consider shunning appropriate).
But telling family (formally or informally) what to do as to association with YOUR OWN FAMILY MEMBERS is wrong, morally wrong, more wrong than the sin that was committed by the shunned one.
Read the bible, particularly the life of Jesus. Then you'll get my point.
ashi