I know exactly how you feel Julia- the same thing happened to me after I woke up to TTATT a couple years ago. I started driving a few miles to a nearby city and went to a couple different churches just to see what it was like.
I met some incredible people, and had one minister (Church of Christ) offer to meet with me and give me some counsel. It was very helpful and he was more knowledgeable on the Bible than anyone I met when I was at Beth-hell. He wasn't looking to sell me anything or "sign me up" for his church. He told me I needed to let my light shine and that sooner or later I would be forced to choose Christ as my leader...he was so right.
Then I tried a couple non-denominational churches and liked both of them. They are fun, non-judgemental and refreshing. The music rocks and is 1,000 times better than King-dumb melodies. Please consider trying one of these out in a neighboring town. And don't sweat the small differences or little things they may have "wrong"...it's so unimportant in the grand scheme.
Hope this helps- keep us up on what's going on. PM me anytime.
Take Care Sis,
Eric