For fellow Beroeans, Gen 49:27

by jonahstourguide 13 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • jonahstourguide
    jonahstourguide

    Thanks for your thoughts folks.

    Cult and Splash, you have described succinctly the thoughts I have, especially when an elder

    asks if you believe the fds is the only channel of communication (with that challenging look!)

    I was asked this over the generation thing and I replied "ok what about this in our bible highlights for tomorrow?"

    He suggested immediately that I'm reading apostate material, my reply " nope I'm quoting from the books in the

    fds library, ring em and check!!" He then suggested we would talk about this again later. I would think that we should be honest and

    admit our roots,,,,. I love engines,,, and I can build a good strong engine based on my years of knowledge and experience.

    If however I was using someone else's expertise, ie a build manual by another engine builder and not tell my clients but continue to

    claim I was the best engine builder, would I not in fact be a charlatan?? especially if I didn't acknowledge the other persons expertise?

    jtg,,,,,,,,, the light does get brighter.

  • snowbird
    snowbird

    Good thoughts, all.

    Ray Franz references this is his first book.

    When he was given the task of helping put together the Aid to Bible Understanding encyclopedia, he stated how impressed he was with the Bible commentaries of old.

    He noted how they have withstood the test of time, in contrast to WT publications which are often here today and gone tomorrow!

    He stated that his uncle, Fred Franz, advised him to consult those commentaries of Christendom as much as possible.

    So, even the so-called Oracle didn't believe his own teachings.

    LOL.

    Sylvia

  • Island Man
    Island Man

    TheOldHippie: But so what? Where does it say that each and every verse of the Bible has to be given a completely new interpretation or comment? Why does it have to wrong to say what a verse says, just because it has been said earlier? So Gill said something, and Henry said something - does that mean that you have to say something completely different?

    The point is they claim that they're the exclusive channel that Jehovah is using to dispense truth and apart from their organization no one can understand the bible. If this is true, how is it that they themselves are feeding off the insight of others in christendom? Is Jehovah really using them, or is he using the scholars in christendom that they get their ideas from? So the fact that they depend on worldly and christedom source exposed their claims of exclusive divine insight as being the pretentious claims of a charlatan. That's what!

  • snowbird
    snowbird

    Yeah, their claim of having special insight on the Scriptures is what drew me and lot of others in.

    I knew just a little of the Bible then, and we know what is said about a little knowledge!

    Sylvia

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit