Johnamos, in Witness-speak, this is not a law but a (general) principle. Should this principle be upheld in every case, especially in the case of child molestation or murder? Certainly this might have worked to some extent in the first century and before, but do you really think it should be applied in the 21st century? Today we have Forensics: fingerprints, DNA, and physical evidence, etc., even better than human witnesses, and more conclusive. So, by not reporting child abuse to the authorities you bury the evidence. Who would you be protecting, the child or the pedophile?
By the way, Johnamos, do you have children? Would you leave them in the care of any of your brothers at the Kingdom Hall? If you do, you're an idiot, because you do not know who the pedophiles are. Only the elders are privy to that information, which they will not share with ordinary publishers. But don't worry, justice for the victims are imminent. If this appeal goes through, it will pave the way for may more cases to be opened against the Watchtower, and their ilk, which will hurt their pocket, and (hopefully) drive them to bankruptcy.