Sleepy,
We are probably in the minority, but I tend to feel much as you do. Sure, it's wonderful to get together with family and dear friends, and eat together, and watch TV together, and have that big turkey or ham.
But, in reality, all the "gift giving" of "things" is usually highly overrated. People "feel" like they are obligated to buy, or make stuff for some people they don't even know that well--but, they would never say it. We humans get so embarrassed when we don't "fit in".
Maybe my vision is distorted by my own personal experiences in youth, before the JW experience, and during the JW experience, when I thought I was missing out. I just tend to feel that the majority of society is very much manipulated. We are like drones, prodding along, buying things we are told will make us happy. Then, poof, in one day, it's all gone anyway....
There is so much more to true gift-giving and sharing. When those gifts are given, they last a lifetime and never wear out, and they cost nothing material. Some people do know this, and they try their best to make it the "old-fashioned" kind of holiday. I admire that. As rich as our society is, there are still so many poor people. We just can't cover that up with wrapping paper, bows and ribbons.