wednesday,
You said:
: Agree, open marriages have been tried, and don't work.
True, they are mostly failures in our Western Culture, but they are not a big deal in many other cultures and haven't been for millenia.
This begs the question about WHY they don't work in Western Culture:
Is it because of religious taboos? Of course, that is the reason. Religion screws up cultures. Period.
They aren't religious taboos in other cultures and other cultures take open marriages for granted. The Aleut males will offer their wives to a visitor for pleasure without having a second thought. The wife of the Aleut male likes the variety and the visitor enjoys the experience as well. This "adultery" doesn't destroy the bond between the Aleut male and his wife. It's just sex. It's not love.
The parents deal with it and the children grow up with that lifestyle as part of their life.
I'm not trying to advocate anything, but to say that "open marriages don't work" as a blanket generalization is not correct. To say it doesn't work in Western society IS correct, and therefore it is worthwhile to find out why it doesn't work in our society, and after all is said and done, the answer becomes evident:
Religion did it.
Farkel