Hi Chris,
: But in retrospect do you think LDS (Mormons) are more or less (what's the word) .... harsh on their members as opposed to Jehovah's Witnesses? By that I mean, do you feel that this religion leaves fewer scars on their believers, creates fewer dysfunctions by their teachings or causes less havoc amongst the general populace than does Jehovah's Witnesses among theirs ?
I don't think the Mormons leave bigger scars on their member and ex-members than JWs.
I visited one of my cousins back in Logan several years ago, and asked him this very question. He served on a mission and was raised in the Mormon religion. He said that when one is disfellowshipped in that faith that shunning is encouraged but not enforced. And he said that under NO circumstances is shunning encouraged OR enforced when it comes to close family members.
Regarding the issue of leaving scars and creating dysfunctions, I can only say this: the Mormon religion IS just another weird and goofy cult, but after living around it and living around the JWs for most of my young life, I can honestly say it is not NEARLY as dangerous as the Watchtower Cult(tm).
The one thing the Mormons and dubs have in common is this: they both worship their human religious masters. But then again, so do the Catholics and many other religions. (I think humans who claim religious authority may be part of the problem here.)
Farkel