Watch Tower PA sues Russia in DC district over confiscation of Bethel

by Corney 10 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • Corney
    Corney

    The Watch Tower Society of Pennsylvania filed a lawsuit on September 3, 2024, naming as defendants the Russian Federation, the Russian Ministry of Health, and the Almazov National Medical Research Center. Unfortunately, I can't access the case documents, including the complaint. I would appreciate if someone with an active PACER account could make them available.

    Anyway, it is enough to know the Almazov Center is one of the entities sued by the WTS to say what this case is about. The said Center operates on the premises of the former Bethel and Assembly Hall in St. Petersburg. The branch properties were owned by Watch Tower Pennsylvania, which is now apparently challenging their unlawful expropriation before US courts.

    This move was predictable from the beginning, probably delayed in anticipation of the European Court's intervention. Surely, judges in Strasbourg awarded the org compensation (50 million euros or so) for property loss - except they did it precisely when Russia abandoned any willingness to follow its international obligations, at least vis-à-vis "unfriendly countries" of the "collective West". Albeit binding, that ruling - as any other issued by the ECHR - can't be forcefully enforced, thus providing little relief for Watch Tower.

    Now, Paul Polidoro is prosecuting the Russian Federation before a US district court. That exactly is the problem - foreign governments are generally entitled to sovereign immunity, and in light of the recent DC circuit's Chabad 2024 ruling it's hard to see how Watch Tower can establish jurisdiction in an American court. But still, I'm not familiar with the complaint, and who knows, maybe our esteemed Esquire will manage to obtain another big victory before SCOTUS. Even so, the prospects of the hunt for Russian assets seem not very bright. Time will tell how this special legal operation will turn out.

  • jwleaks
  • NotFormer
    NotFormer

    I'm in two minds about this. Unusually, I'm on the WT's side. Russia is indulging in religious persecution, and that is not right, no matter how much I despise the WT. Here comes the big "however", however. By valuing their monetary assets over their adherents, they are arguably endangering said adherents further. It'd be nice if, just once, the WT would genuinely care about the welfare of their congregants over their material wealth.

  • jwleaks
    jwleaks

    Methinks Watch Tower is seeking a default judgment (maybe a ‘no show’ in a USA court by the Russia Federation) so they can pursue a claim against the seized assets of the Russian Federation.

    Russia should offer to give the real estate back and have the documents prepared as such. When Watch Tower representatives are a ‘no show’ in a Russian Federation court then the subject could be moot.

    On the other hand, this could be an insurance claim.

    Either way this could be very dangerous for JW’s in Russia and result in an increase in persecution.

  • Corney
    Corney

    I'm not seeing why Russia would default, albeit for some tactical reasons, which is unlikely. Nothing prevents it from hiring a law firm, appearing in court, and preparing and presenting its defense.

    I also don't think this litigation will significantly change the situation of Jehovah's Witnesses in Russia, given the current state of affairs. First, it's not that important for the Russian government when you compare $30-50 million at stake here (not to mention the limited prospects of success) with, say, one billion dollars in the Oschadbank case, five billion dollars in the Naftogaz case, and fifty billion dollars in the Yukos case, all litigated before American courts right now. Second, it's not like the Russian authorities restrain themselves now. The scale and nature of the persecution are limited by the capacity of law enforcement, given their priorities and the complexity of the criminal procedure (the amount of paperwork, etc.). A drastic increase in persecution is not impossible, but it is unlikely to be caused by the lawsuit in question. On the other hand, some response from the government can be expected, which ain't good for Witnesses in Russia.

  • Vidiot
    Vidiot

    Meaningless plastic saber-rattling that’s just going to get more people hurt.

  • liam
    liam

    Russia Responds; "COME ON OVER AND TAKE THEM"

  • Gorb
    Gorb

    Maybe jw.org wants compensation from the sanction funds. $$$$$$$$$

    Were money is, there is a Watchtower lawyer.

    Gorby

  • Corney
  • NotFormer
    NotFormer

    Most organisations, both religious and secular, would probably "take the L" materially in order to protect their people living in those situations. The WT have no such scruples.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit