They determine repentance by the amount of groveling by the "condemned".
I was once told by my old hall's PO, James Kelly currently somewhere in Atlanta, an uptight pompous self-righteous effiminate limp-wristed masturbation-obsessed useless damn-yankee, the things I'd have to do in order to be considered for reinstatement. At all times, either be at work, home, or at every meeting. While at home, nothing but studying the Society's publications. No going out with friends. No TV. No movies. No recreation. Lose the worldly girlfriend. Once I'd done all that, contact them and "we'll talk about it".
My kid brother has been going thru the same ordeal. He's self employed as an interior contractor (wallpaper and stuff like that). His work takes him all over the place so sometimes he can't make the meeting at his home congregation and goes to the nearest KH. But he makes all the meetings. That's strike one against him as far as the elders are concerned. If he's not at their Hall, they don't consider him to be making the meeting. One of them also told him that he should study every day. Well so he misses a day sometimes. Strike two. Little petty trivial shit like that is preventing his reinstatement. I'll give the guy credit, he's busting his ass to get reinstated. But just this one jerkoff elder is holding the whole thing up, seeing how much he can make my brother crawl and beg. And getting off on the whole power trip.
F*ck those assholes! If they want me to come back they can start kissing my ass!
Mike.
p.s. All of you northerners please don't take offense at my use of "yankee" in the derogatory sense. Not all yankees are like James Kelly. (fortunately)
p.s.s. Any of you lurkers in Atlanta who recognize the name James Kelly......Steer clear of the man! I know that he was not too long ago removed from his position as elder. Not sure why, but I have heard "some things". Keep your kids away from him too.