LANDMARK DECISION - Vicki Boer vs Watchtower Society

by Uzzah 144 Replies latest watchtower child-abuse

  • Uzzah
    Uzzah

    As most are aware, Vicki Boer has been long awaiting a decision to be handed down in a case she started against the Society in Canada.

    The decision was handed down today. As with any 55 page decision, it will take some time for the legal experts to hash it over and decipher what was said. But, in a nutshell....

    Vicki won. Not much by way of $$$ in fact a paltry sum of $5,000. But in the Judge's own handwriting in announcing the Order she wrote, "$5,000 for negligence against the Watchtower Society." The local elders were not found to be culpable but the Society corporately was.

    Financially this is insulting but compared to the Canadian standard of extremely low costs awarded even against the perpetrators of the most extreme child abuse ($75,000-$150,000 CDN) it is large enough to be noticed by the Society.

    There is some language in the decision that is absolutely HUGE by way of opening the door for further lawsuits. The Judge gave an excellent write up regarding the stranglehold the Borg has on its adherents. i.e While it is true Vicki was legally an adult when she attended the committee meetings to confront her abuser, she was by no means capable of free will to decide not to attend due to the relationship and power held over her by the church.

    The Judge also spent about 10 pages explaining why in Canada the freedoms given to religion are NOT absolute and damage to an individual supercedes the rights of a religion.

    So while the amount is not large, the fact that any damages were awarded is a victory since it has never happened before to the WT Society over an abuse case. It is historic.

    Vicki is shocked by the small amount but is somewhat bolstered by the gains legally for future cases. Awarding of costs of the court case is going to be battled out by the lawyers. So Vicki will likely end up out of pocket for at least some of her legal costs.

    This is something we as a community can possibly assist with once the final amount is known and perhaps some can help out as they are able.

    Thank you to all those who have been of support in this case and please continue to show Vicki your appreciation for her strength and determination in exposing the Borg for what they truly are, uncaring selfish egoists interested only in covering their collective ass.

    I look forward to hearing the comments of those more learned than myself as the decisions itself gets analyzed.

    Uzzah

  • kgfreeperson
    kgfreeperson

    This is shaping up to be a very exciting legal week!

  • Pleasuredome
    Pleasuredome

    great news! congrats vicki!!

    what i want to know is, did the judge make any comment on the fact that the WTS lawyers claimed that the WTS had no duty of care?

  • neverthere
    neverthere

    Wow, at least she won, I wonder how many who were so against her and didn't believe her feel now. I know that it was not a large sum of money but it is something.

    Congratulations Vicki!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    We knew you would do it!!!!!!!!!

    Love Diana

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    Is it just me, or is this a big step, "the freedoms given to religion are NOT absolute and damage to an individual supercedes the rights of a religion"

  • Scully
    Scully

    jgnat writes:

    Is it just me, or is this a big step, "the freedoms given to religion are NOT absolute and damage to an individual supercedes the rights of a religion"

    You bet your sweet bippy it is!! This is a major kick in the teeth for the WTS. Love, Scully

  • jst2laws
    jst2laws

    This is GOOD! Very GOOD!

    Been waiting a long time to hear this. Thanks to Vickie for challenging them and winning.

    Jst2

  • ignored_one
    ignored_one

    ((((((((((Vicki))))))))))

    Nice one!!

    Ignored One.

  • Cassiline
    Cassiline
    "the freedoms given to religion are NOT absolute and damage to an individual supercedes the rights of a religion"

    What a statement!

    she was by no means capable of free will to decide not to attend due to the relationship and power held over her by the church.

    What a victory!

    My gradtitude to the Judge.

    (((( Vicki ))))

    I know as an abuse survivor myself that this "victory" must seem 'hollow' to you. Yet, what I see is a historic decision which was rendered because you paved the way for all survivors of such abuse to be reconized as a seperate entity from the rigors of religious indoctranation.

    Because of your bravery and tenaciousness abuse victims everywhere can know that they have not suffered in vain. They can have hope that because of what you did all potential victims will not ever have to worry about hiding their head in shame, realizing that justice is out there and will be met out.

    The society will not be as quick to hide or allow by written doctrine children to be abused, or medical treatment withheld, psychological or even perhaps in the case of blood transfusions.

    This decision can and I am sure be used in future cases other then abuse.

    Thank you Vicki, thank you for all your bravery, know that you are loved, respected and held in high esteem.

    Love

    Cassi

  • little witch
    little witch

    (((((((((((((((((((Vicki))))))))))))))))))))

    Congratulations dear one, the amount is an insult, but this is a historic legal step, and yours is only the beginning. Way to go hon !!!!

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit