From reading all through this I can at least say I'm not the only guy who feels really clueless lots of times about "what women want." And who's missing subtle clues as to her meanings.
Maybe part of the problem is we tend to assume all women speak with one voice. It ought to be obvious they don't, but....
Me, I tend to be the type of guy who considers questions that really aren't that interesting to others, for example. To give you an idea how awkward that can be, remember how difficult it is talking to a non-JW about your experiences in the Society? I have that same gulf mentally with many people at work, and with women.
The relevance of that to the thread title? I could be getting totally straight treatment from women, she might find me fascinating, and yet I'd miss it because of their subtlety.
And being an introverted type...non-drinker, mainy because of my diabetes...homebody...I feel very out of touch and not on the same frequency with women, as far as being "the type of guy" women'd find interesting. Very shy around them, which doesn't help. I'd have a terrible time if I had to begin dating again. So it's not a case of me being either manipulated (or otoh being the game player) so much as it is a feeling of mismatch between what's sought and what I'd have to offer. Reason tells me if I were dating again there'd be someone desiring those qualities I mentioned earlier...experience before I got married says otherwise. Still does, in social situations, which can be a "low key" dating situation.
So while I don't consider myself a "player" and I wouldn't be trying to con a woman into the sack, I probably missed many opportunities to meet someone because I was ignorant of her true meaning. I ended up blindsiding myself. I can't blame women for that.
I hope this makes sense. I know what I want to say but I'm not sure it's coming through.