Shunning RAP (or any type) Music - Why the Hard Line by the WTS?

by Funchback 13 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • Funchback
    Funchback

    I grew up in the late 70's, early 80's. I remember hearing the first Rap song called 'Rapper's Delight' by the Sugar Hill Gang. Then came Kurtis Blow and Grand Master Flash and the Furious Five. Taking it a new level was Run-DMC. Then, came LL Cool J and Boogie Down Productions. After that, there was Eric B. and Rakim and Public Enemy. Some of the music was original and some were "looped" beats from other songs.

    One thing was certain: Rap was here to stay. In this, the year 2003, Rap is global. It also has crossed-over in to white and suburbia America. It is listened to in Brazil, China, and Japan. It is everywhere!

    Some of the songs are politcal, some are about social awareness. Some are about bragging, some are about the hard life on the ghetto streets. Some are simple, some are filled with deep meaning. In other words, like ALL genre's of music, Rap has a message and it ranges from easy/fun to hardcore. Many Pop/R&B songs have a Rapper say something in the middle of it.

    Still, even when Rap was in its' infantile stage, the WTS suggested that we not listen to it at ALL! They would always seem to couple Rap and Heavy Metal together and say something like, "We're not saying ALL Rap music is bad. But, if it's bad as a WHOLE, wouldn't it be wise NOT to listen to it?" You remember, don'tcha?

    In response, I would like to quote some verses from the Kingdom Melodies. Since Kingdom Melodies are bad as a whole, I have decided to shun that type of music.

    Song 3 verse: "God Jehovah does the fighting; Fire from him his foes devours." (Violence)

    Song 12 verse: "All our time and resources, to Jehovah they do belong. If to him we do give them, we will never go wrong." (Greed)

    Song 18 title: "Bless Our Christian Brotherhood" (Selfishness)

    Song 36 verse: "The wicked do not make them fret, Who proudly set themselves on high. They know such won't get life eternal, but will, like green grass, fade and die." (Negativity)

    FINALLY, since I am FRANKLY getting SICK from reading thorugh these friggin' songs, here's a litlle gem that should stoke all of your fires:

    Song 38: "Displaying Loyalty"

    "To God's loyal congregation We too will show loyalty, Give it our steadfast allegiance Even in adversity."

    "Loyally we'll help our brothers, Whether new ones or the weak, Both in study and in service With assistance kind and meek. And, as a family circle, we will never rouse distrust, But show that in each relation Loyalty will be a must."

    "In this world that's so disloyal, Loyalty we will display T'ward all those to whom it's owing As we walk the Christian way."

  • greven
    greven

    Maybe it was the nature of it in the fist place. Um they were and are mostly protest songs against society, the system, poverty and important: authority. Hence there dislike of rap from the start. Hmm the swearing helps too.

    On the other hand the wtbs had a thing against Rock 'n roll, blues Jazz and you name it. even the twist was banned I mean...C'mon! They are control freaks and this is just a symptom of that attitude. "we old farts don't like and so should you" kinda spirit.

    Greven, Yo!

  • Room 215
    Room 215

    It isn't just JWs who find much of the Rap scene offensive, because a large proportion of it is self-pitying, self-indulgent, foul-mouthed, and obscene.

  • Black Man
    Black Man

    At Bethel, it was a witchhunt for those that had rap music in their rooms. I know a few brothers who were sent home because of it.

  • minimus
    minimus

    Quite simply, the Society FROWNS upon any "worldly" music. If they could make people not listen to the radio, they would be happy. They have a history of attacking EVERY type of music, whether it be classical (because the performer was homosexual), jazz, rock and roll, country (because of possible immorality). Rock and roll means "To fornicate".....So R&R is wrong for Christians.....They HATE everything. And for the record, Kingdom Melodies S U C K .

  • Room 215
    Room 215

    Minimus, re JW FROWNING: Ideally, they would love nothing better than have JWs rely on the Watchtower and Awake! as their lone source of news, features and worldview; their tapes as their only television, and Kingdom Melodies as their only music.

  • Mulan
    Mulan
    It isn't just JWs who find much of the Rap scene offensive, because a large proportion of it is self-pitying, self-indulgent, foul-mouthed, and obscene.

    Good comment.

  • integ
    integ

    It's funny that people like to attack Rap music for the "message" Rap music sends out. But glorify people like Johnny Cash who recorded a song called 'Folsom Prison Blues"...Let's take a look at some of the lyrics of what is considered to be a "Classic".........

    " Well I shot a man in Reno.....Just to watch him die" (loud cheers from the audience).

    Don't get me wrong, I like Johnny Cash. I also used to dig some Ice T stuff. I also like classical music, despite it's 'Satanic melodies' (lol). I'm all over the place w/music. I hate dixieland jazz though, it gives me a headache.

    Integ.

  • Badger
    Badger

    The society takes this stance with Rap...and Rock...and Jazz...and Sports...and Pokemon...and Smurfs...and MTV...and Paintball....and Video games...

    They harp on just about every new think that comes down the pike that gets attention, especially of the young ones. Like most out of the youth loop, they don't get it. And while most parents allow their children to participate without doing much aside from rolling their eyes, The society uses their authority to clamp down on it. Easy to tell a kid he/she can't listen/play/watch when you have the FDS's authority.

  • Nosferatu
    Nosferatu

    I'm really surprised that I haven't ever heard of the Society frowning upon their old Kingdom Melodies. They're just like the old publications - Old Light.

    Frown, frown frown. The Society would never be able to do a review on a product, because it would find SOMETHING satanic about it. People would become terrified of their own lives.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit