Shunning RAP (or any type) Music - Why the Hard Line by the WTS?

by Funchback 13 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • undercover
    undercover
    It's funny that people like to attack Rap music for the "message" Rap music sends out. But glorify people like Johnny Cash who recorded a song called 'Folsom Prison Blues"...Let's take a look at some of the lyrics of what is considered to be a "Classic".........

    " Well I shot a man in Reno.....Just to watch him die" (loud cheers from the audience).

    The context of violence in songs like Johnny Cash's opposed to a lot of the "violent" songs of today is different. When you listen to a Cash song, you sense that he(or his character in the song) knew that what he did was wrong and often time in the song paid the consequences.

    From his first album under Rick Rubin, the song Delia sings about how if he had not shot her he would have made her his wife and the first shot didn't kill her but the second round did. But later in the song he speaks to the jailor, so we know that he is paying the price for his mistake. We sense the anquish and regret in his voice.

    A lot of songs today seem to want to justify the violence used. They rationalize the actions taken as doing nothing wrong and as the only course available. Thus it glorifys the violence and mayhem portrayed in the music.

    All that aside though, a lot of hardliner JWs or elders would want to discourage you from listening to Johnny Cash either due to the violence in his music or because he sang gospel from time to time or because of his relationship with Billy Graham.

  • shamus
    shamus

    They are so two-faced!

    I used to listen to music that people thought was horrible just to get a rise out of them... remember the Michael Jackson scare?? I sure don't... but one day out in service there was this old guy whining about Mickey Jackson and how horrible his music was... a younger bro and I were singing his songs for the rest of the service day... SUCKER!

    Why was I never an MS?

  • Funchback
    Funchback

    Hello, all.

    I don't agree with some comments of the responses that some of you have posted, but I am not here to change your opinion of Rap. I guess it just depends on your experience in life. For example, I just don't get Country or Heavy Metal music. But, still, I'm not going to lump all of the songs together and say that it's all bad/socially irresponsible/"self-pitying" (as one person said). MY experince with MUCH Rap has been good.

    Also, say what you want about "many" people or groups feeling the same way as the WTS. Probably, Rap music is the most popular choice of music amoung youth today. Also, those who are older (like yours truly) who grew up listening to Rap, especially enjoy the "Old School Rap". Which led to my point in the first place:

    I'll say it again: Even when Rap was in its' infantile stages, the WTS suggested that we "stay away" from it. This was done at a time when MOST of Rap songs were about fun "battles" of who could make the better rhymes (LL vs. Kool Moe D / UTFO vs. Roxanne / MC Shan vs. KRS-One). The songs were intelligent, funny, and often fantasy-filled. Yet, the WTS still didn't want us to listen to it because, as a whole (???), Rap music was bad.

    Saying not to DO something because it is "bad as a whole" is like saying, "Don't watch any movies (or television)" or "Don't listen to ANY music" or "Don't watch the news (or read an newspaper)" or, dare we say, "Don't eat anymore food because food as a whole is bad!"

    As ridiculous as that sounds, that is, in effect, what the WTS is saying. The REAL focus should be to pick and choose what songs you will listen to, what movies you will watch, what articles in the newspaper you will read, or what type of food you will eat. Hell, isn't that the beauty of being individuals? We (at least much of the world) have the freedom of choice.

  • kilroy2
    kilroy2

    I had a neighbor olie that would have wine and cheese parties around a camp fire and sing these stupid pieces of crap all night long.. I would turn up acdc and rock on. the songs are meant for the dull minded to keep the enthusiasm going, every thing is about control, I was at Jack Arnolds house, he was an elder in Arcadia, and he was showing me his fish tank, and asked what I collected, I told him firearms. he gave me a look and said that is the forbidden hobby. I asked what is not forbidden in this religion except collecting fish? I was never on jacks list of approved association,

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit