Scoob, I think you should try to go back. Give yourself one more shot at it. It's clear you are wrestling with this issue, and a couple of others as well. And really if the Witnesses aren't right, it is kind of scary, isn't it?
I have a terrible fear of failure, it drives me to stick my neck out and to keep trying in the face of failure. I also have a terrible fear of success, in that I'm afraid that if I write a novel it will be published, or if I have a career I'll advance. I'm afraid of success because then I don't have any excuses anymore. I won't have anything to blame on why I'm not more than I am. I see the same thing in you.
You know in your gut who you are, and where you need to be. But it's really quite frightening to actually reach out for it, isn't it? It would mean going against what others have told you is right. It would mean standing up on your own and instead saying "THIS is right". And so I say go back to the meetings. You've changed since you left and I think you would find they have changed as well. You must prove to yourself once and for all who and what you are meant to be in the life. Going back is one way to determine that.
But before you go back, do me a favour. Read, with an open mind, these three threads. After you read them, consider the implications. And then, as I've said above, go back to the meetings. Try it on, like a new suit. If it fits you'll know. If it doesn't, you'll know. Keep an open mind, and don't force it one way or the other. Anyway, read this for me:
http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/6/5466/1.ashx
http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/6/7913/1.ashx
http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/6/10417/1.ashx
Chris