by NotFormer 30 Replies latest watchtower beliefs
Did Rutherford have any "prophetic" justification for 1919 as the date that Jesus declared him (ahem, the WT organisation) the FDS? Such as some calculation attached to 1914? That in 1919, Jesus would come looking for His true organisation?
Or was it purely because he was released from prison? And therefore he pulled a complete extra-biblical doctrine out of his butt?
It was the 3.5 year thing that they came up with through some obscure reasoning. End of 1914 plus three and a half years was the beginning of 1919.
Dont ask me how I was ever stupid enough to believe all this total nonsense
Thats what a lot of us here ask themselves.
Malachi 3:1-3 mentions an inspection of the spiritual temple, followed by a time of cleansing. But the justification for the year 1919 can be found in Revelation 11 and the prophecy about the "two witnesses".
It describes a short period of 42 months when the "two witnesses preached in sackcloth"
(from Autumn 1914 to Spring 1918). They were then symbolically killed (by imprisonment) but were brought back to life in the early part of 1919. This is discussed in a Question from Readers in WT November, 2014.
They now only give seasons even though 1260 days or 42 months is more specific.
Get ready to
[ 11-15-14 WT p. 30 - Revelation 11:3 speaks of two witnesses who would prophesy for 1,260 days. The account then says that the wild beast would “conquer them and kill them.” But after “three and a half days,” these two witnesses would be brought back to life, much to the amazement of all onlookers.—Rev. 11:7, 11.]…[At the end of their preaching in sackcloth, these anointed ones were symbolically killed when they were thrown into prison for a comparatively shorter period of time, a symbolic three and a half days.]
[g01 11/22 p. 18-19 - FIRST, you may be interested to learn when and how Jehovah’s Witnesses originally entered this prison. It was July 4, 1918. A group of eight distinguished Christian ministers were escorted up the 15 granite steps of this federal penitentiary. If the common practice of the time was followed, they were handcuffed to “belly-chains,” with their legs shackled. The newcomers were spiritually qualified men who took the lead among the International Bible Students, as Jehovah’s Witnesses were then known. Those men could not have guessed that it would take less than a year to establish that their imprisonment was a gross miscarriage of justice. In March 1919, the eight Witness ministers walked down those same prison steps, unshackled and free. They were later exonerated when the authorities decided to withdraw the prosecution.]
The WTS claim (not shown here) from Oct 1914 to April 1918 the two-witnesses preached for the 1,260 days. Then in July 1918 when they went to prison that was the wild beast killing them and then in March 1919 when they got out of prison that is them being brought back to life after 3 and half days.
WTS did good math with Oct 1914 to April 1918 because that is 3 years 6 months like the 1,260 days but when it comes to so-called being killed for 3 and half days, that turn out to be 8 months, July 1918 to March 1919.
Next thing is that the beast that is said to kill the two-witnesses, the WTS says it is the UN. Problem is the UN did not exist in 1918. It did not come about until 1945. The League of Nations was not even around in 1918. That didn't come about until 1920 according to the WTS.
[Rev 17:8 The wild beast that you saw was, but is not, and yet is about to ascend out of the abyss, and it is to go off into destruction.]
[Revelation Grand Climax p. 246-248 - “The wild beast . . . was.” Yes, it had existed as the League of Nations from January 10, 1920, onward,]…[The scarlet-colored wild beast did indeed climb out of the abyss. On June 26, 1945, with noisy fanfare in San Francisco, U.S.A., 50 nations voted to accept the Charter of the United Nations organization.]
[Rev 11: 3 I will cause my two witnesses to prophesy for 1,260 days dressed in sackcloth.”7 When they have finished their witnessing, the wild beast that ascends out of the abyss will wage war with them and conquer them and kill them 11 After the three and a half days, spirit of life from God entered into them, and they stood on their feet, and great fear fell upon those who saw them.]
So how did the UN/wild beast put the 8 men in prison in July 1918?
And why is the 1,260 days 42 months/3 and half years, but the 3 and half days are 8 months?
Thanks everyone for filling me in on this. The 1919 date always seemed a bit odd to me, if it was connected to 1914. A difference of five years isn't a very biblical number; it's always 7 or 3.5, in those prophetic passages that the WT loves. That they stretched out the 3.5 makes sense, in a warped sort of way (to me, it smacks of desperation). It's nice to know that they at least tried to create a (albeit tenuous) connection with something biblical. 🙄
It's all about 1919 for the WTS. If they lost that year, they lose the so-called appointment of being appointed the F&DS and they don't want that, so they have to keep lying about the rest of the years that they used to arrive at 1919.
Oct 607B.C.E.>>2,520 years later>Oct 1914C.E.>>1,260 days later>April 1918/July 1918>March 1919
[w16 March p. 29 - All the evidence indicates that this captivity ended in 1919 when anointed Christians were gathered into the restored congregation. Consider: God’s people were tested and refined during the years following the establishment of God’s Kingdom in the heavens in 1914. (Mal. 3:1-4) Then, in 1919, Jesus appointed “the faithful and discreet slave” over God’s cleansed people to give them spiritual “food at the proper time.” (Matt. 24:45-47) This was the year that God’s people started to return to their God-given spiritual estate. It was also the time when they were released from symbolic captivity to Babylon the Great. (Rev. 18:4)]
Please read '' The Gentile Times Reconsidered'' by Carl Olaf Jonson.
It puts the WT theology of 607 BCE,,,to bed.
"Please read '' The Gentile Times Reconsidered'' by Carl Olaf Jonson.*
It puts the WT theology of 607 BCE,,,to bed."
A contributor on here Jeffro had a Web Page that was very easy to understand, plus a good number of Threads and comments on here.
It is vital to appreciate the error and nonsense of 607 BCE, as then the whole Tower of Lies falls, like a House of Cards.
No 1914 = no 1919 "choosing" = Today's G.B are self-appointed Charlatans ! Which means their opinions on anything are just that, the opinions of deluded fraudsters.
* When I was just "waking up" I used to long for 1914 to be totally debunked, I was shocked to read C.O.Jonson's Letter to the Org. from before he wrote his Book, explaining the 1914 error in such detail they could not mistake the import of what he said, I thought to myself "They knew all along it was wrong ! They still know, but carry on conning the J.W's and the Public ! What Liars !".
