Appointed by Holy Spirit?
You'll be suggesting that HS is present in judicial committees next lol.
One of the elders in my former congregation before he was appointed felt he must clear up something with my friend, a young sister. He asked her if she was going to ever mention the fact that several years earlier he had sexually abused her. He said he was very sorry but he obviously was not regretful enough to confess his sins to the elders about to hand him the privelege of overseeing the congregation.
My friend promised to keep mum which was not hard as she was not exactly dying to shout it from the rooftops as most victims of abuse feel shame themselves.
This guy is still an elder to this day and the whole pathetic episode was all the proof I needed that HS is not involved in appointment of elders.
Free