I find overly 'buff' men a real turn off. I guess you could say I prefer the boy next door type...men who are just regular guys--not too skinny, not all grotesquely muscled up, but who can flex a bicep in the mirror aftter a morning shower and look cute as hell doing it.
If I were looking around the room and picking out the men I am most attracted to, they'd generally be the 'average' ones--men who are clean cut, have nice smiles and a twinkle in their eye when they look back at me. My husband describes himself as 'painfully average'. I, of course, think he's nothing of the sort--he's the most extraordinary man I've ever known, and the handsomest man on earth.