After I left the WTS I stopped reading religious materials completely. I made a slight switch into philosophy. I believe the first two books I read after leaving the WTS were Nietzsche's Twilight of the Idols and Beyond Good and Evil. That lead me into reading a very wide range of seemingly unrelated philosophers, anyone from Sun Tzu(The Art of War), to Thomas More(Utopia), to Machiavelli(The Prince), to Plato(The Republic), to Lao Tzu(Tao Te Ching) to Noam Chomsky(Necessary Illusions). I was trying to find anything to help me better understand the world and in a way those books all did.
Later in college I had to do a systematic study of philosophy all the way from the ancients like Heraclites and Anaxagoras to the more contemporary like Jean-Paul Sartre, Peter Singer, and John Rawls. And let me just digress and say that after all that I once almost embraced existentialism and totally abhor utilitarian philosophy.
After I got all of that philosophy junk out of my system I read virtually ever single book published by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Jack Kerouac, William S. Burroughs, Irvine Welsh, Thomas Harris, Stephen King, Albert Camus and a load of books by Ernest Hemingway, Kurt Vonnegut, John Steinbeck, Jean Genet, Ivan Turgenev, Anton Chekhov, Alexander Solzhenitsyn -- a diverse group, but all worth reading.
I also own and have read nearly the entire poetic works of William Shakespeare (wrote some fantastic sonnets), Silvia Plath, Ted Hughes, Edgar Allan Poe and Robert Frost.
These days I find myself reading less books and print, in general. I find myself much more interested in reading the content of The Economist, the NYT, and the Washington Post. In fact, I'm only reading one book at the present and it is a laughable work written by Rick Warren. It's a book for the Christian fundamentalist out there, wrought with contrived emotionalism ? you know the whole, "Jesus loves you so much" gibberish. I'm about half way through it and I'm not sure if my stomach is going to allow me to finish.
So, I guess I read more.