American Idol again (page 2)

zev

fantasia sucked.

her voice sounds like aunt Esther on sanford and son.

WildHorses

Diana and Latoya were the best tonight IMO.

zev

i guess we'll see if i eat my computer tommorow night now

BeautifulGarbage

Just when Jennifer hits her stride, she gets voted off.

My boy, George, has been very disappointing the last few times. He had better get it together or he is gonna be a goner.

I'm not sure what to think about Fantasia.

LaToya is the best singer in the competition.

Diana is very good, but I have to agree with Simon, she acts, and sounds, like she came through the pagent circuit.

I like Jasmine, but knock it off with the hands already! She good, but not exceptional at this point.

There doesn't really seem to be a front runner. They have all, for the most part, had their good and bad performances.

wasasister

I guess Fantasia is an aquired taste as she is not a pop singer. Her version of "Summertime" from Porgy and Bess is probably the best I've ever heard - any time, any singer.

She would be great at Billy Holliday songs, as her voice is that kind of jazz style.

You may not care for her personality, but unlike some of the others, her pitch is flawless.

RevMalk

LaToya will most likely win, with Diana a close 2nd.

George has the coolest personality but I can't stand listening to him. Jennifer I liked but didn't cry when she left. Her buggy eyes drove me insane as well. I know that's superficial but oh well. I liked John alot and was sad to see him go. Tonight would have been his night. I like Fantasia, but Diana has to be my favorite - she needs to be a country singer though, but hell that's where the money is.

Rev

Gopher

I had George as my early favorite, but he never ramped up his performance -- he seems to have hit a plateau. Same for Jasmine.

That leaves Fantasia, Diana and LaToya, just like Randy Jackson said. I think the public likes Diana and LaToya the best out of those three. Both of them may have very nice careers in entertainment if they play their cards right.

flower

they all have their niche market and its tough because you had big band singers like john going against r & b singers like latoya and country singers like diana going against jazz singers like fantasia. all are pretty good in their particular style of music but they are all trying to be 'pop' stars and most of them it doesnt work for.

george stinks and he blinks all the damn time.

i agree with you wasasister, i wasnt crazy about fantasia but she blew me away when she sang summertime a few weeks ago.

RevMalk

george stinks and he blinks all the damn time.

LOL!

Fleur

guess i'm the only fantasia fan in the house lol. she could have done better tonight IMO but to me, she is the one with the most unique voice and style and i think she rocks. diana oversang "someone to watch over me" badly IMO, it's supposed to be a very brooding, melancholy song and at times i felt like she sounded like a miss america contestant lol.

i think it will definitely come down to her, fantasia and la toya. right now i hope fantasia wins, latoya should be on broadway, and diana needs to finish growing up.

just the way i see it!

fleur

American Idol again

Share this