Sassy,
I think blonde is not you at all. Too pale for you. The black in my opinion is almost too harsh for your complexion.After you wash your hair a few times it should soften to a very pretty shade. The auburn would be my pick.....but.....I have worked in three salons as an apprentice and I am also very artistic. I'd think you would look best in soft cool brown. You need the softer color because you have a soft, delicate skintone. You have a very feminine and youthful face. I think of you as the romantic style with soft feminine touches and a softer brown in a medium tone would look lovely on you. Eyeliner in the same color but softer, a little lighter shade would be flattering. The eyeliner you have on in your new avatar pic is a little on the dark side for your coloring. Maybe you could blend it a little with a softer shade of the same color?
I like the straight bangs in the auburn pic the best. You would look cute with your bangs brushed all in the same direction toward the left or right. Still bangs, just brushed to an angle. A college girl at work has her bangs like that.Her face is shaped a lot like yours. On you it would look enchanting.
Flyin'