American Idol final: Diana or Fantasia

by Mulan 23 Replies latest social entertainment

  • FlyingHighNow
    FlyingHighNow
    Taht being said, she could do w/ out what i see as a modern problem w/ modern soul music, all the yeahyeahhhyeah vibrato BS, I guess people like that , but I see it over used and a crutch. Waht happened to honest R and B?

    I agree about the vibrato. It never sounds good and it's way overused and run into the ground. Fantasia has been my pick since day one. I have to say though that I did not like her adding vibrato to Summertime. Edit: I did not like the vibrato. It must have sounded better live because even Simon seemed blown away by her performance of Summertime.

    Now, all of you are going to hate me but I must say I am very glad Diana did NOT win. The girl has the most annoying and fake facial expressions. She has no idea how to dress for her figure and looks like a wobbling sack of melons when she dances. She is off key more than on. Sweet and young? Yes she is but that doesn't mean she should have won.Really she needs a couple of years of vocal lessons. She needs to give up on the dancing. She is not a good dancer and never will be. She can take her raw singing talent and learn to sing well. She can have someone with fashion sense help dress her for her figure. She can have someone teach her how to avoid the phony facial expressions and then she might be idol material.

    I really hated to see Latoya go. She's gorgeous, dresses superbly and can sing to boot.

  • CountryGuy
    CountryGuy

    I wanted Diana to win , but was almost as happy for Fantasia.

    I prefer Diana's voice to Fantasia's by all means, but I liked Fantasia's personality. During the "Specials" where Ryan Seacrest would interview the Top Five or Top Three... Fantasia came across as a very likeable, very down to earth kind of gal. What was the first thing she did after being announced as the 2004 American Idol? She put Diana in a death grip/hug and then told Ryan, "I broke my shoe!" To me, that's a very real reaction. But my all time favorie Fantasia quote was when Ryan asked her what new luxury she discovered while being on AI. Her answer, "FOOD!" Now that's my kind of woman!!!!

    Now, I'm off to shave my beard because I lost my American Idol bet with my boss.

    Country

  • LyinEyes
    LyinEyes

    I picked Fantasia to win. I find that she is so down to earth,,,,,a great singer , a very real person. I am pleased that she won. The girl could belt out an Aretha Franklin song,,,,,,,,so there ya go.

  • bebu
    bebu

    When Fantasia was singing her "winner" song and toward the end was on the floor, really really saying the words ("I believe!") with tears coming down her cheeks, it was so moving... I got quite choked up.

    bebu

    Edited to add: you can see the final performance if you go to idolonfox.com.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit