Did I go too far / How far would you go to protect your partner ?

by bull01lay 26 Replies latest jw friends

  • bull01lay
    bull01lay

    Had a bit of an altercation this weekend... my Nephew in Law attempted to assault my wife....

    This is the background:

    I have a deaf mute nephew with a personality disorder. He's 32, and still lives with his mother and her fiancee. He has terrible mood swings, and has taken it out on his mother many times, leaving her battered and bruised. Her boyfriend has never done anything about it because she ALWAYS excuses him because he is deaf, and 'doesn't understand'!! She calls the police, and each time they arrive and he turns on the tears, she feels guilty and refuses to press charges. The way I see it, she is creating a maniac who thinks he can just hit women and get away with it.

    He learnt the hard way on Saturday. He had been in a bad mood for most of the day, and ended up arguing with my wife over someting very trivial - he put WWF wrestling on and then left the room, and sat down at the PC. She turned the tv over to another channel, at which he flew into a rage. Normally, my wife is very mild mannered, and did try to explain that she thought he wasn;t interested in the programme, and it's no bother, he could put it back on. But that wasn't good enough, and in the end she started shouting back at him. His mother overheard, and just got between them as he lunged for my wife. As it happened, he only grazed her arm - his mother deflected the full force of the blow. My wife gathered up her things and left; as she left, her sister asked her if he hit her, to which she replied yes, and showed her the mark.

    I won't go into the details of the fight that ensued - I'm not writing this with the intention of gloryfing violence, or bragging. Suffice to say, I walked away after making my point, but he hadn't finished. He ran into the kitchen, and grabbed a heavy bottle, then hit me at the back of the head with it - so I had to make my 'point' again, this time using a little more force!!

    There are a few things that have stuck in my mind;

    1) The eyes of a maniac, filled with sheer hatred as he tried to hit me with the bottle again, intent on doing some real damage.

    2) The eyes of a coward - filled with terror as I stepped into his attack, deflected his blow and grabbed him by his collars.

    3) The lies of a mother. She knows what a violent, vicious little bastard he is, and yet tried to tell me (and the police) that her son didn't hit my wife.

    On the third point - is this normal ?? Would you lie to 'protect' your partner, even if you knew they were in the wrong ??

    Would you take revenge if someone hurt, or threatened, your family ? If so, to what point would you say is reasonable ?

    Bull!

  • Undecided
    Undecided

    He seems dangerous and should be put in a care facility somewhere.

    Ken P.

  • Sirona
    Sirona

    Sounds awful.

    On the third point - is this normal ??

    No, but unfortunately some people are like that.

    Would you lie to 'protect' your partner, even if you knew they were in the wrong ??

    Definately not. They need to face the repercussions of their actions and if you cover up you're condoning their actions.

    Would you take revenge if someone hurt, or threatened, your family ? If so, to what point would you say is reasonable ?

    If someone hurt my family I would call the police. I would also do my best to put protections in place to prevent further damage. I don't have kids though, so I'm not sure if I'd be moved to revenge if someone hurt my kid.

    Sirona

  • frenchbabyface
    frenchbabyface

    Sorry Bull !

    she feels guilty and refuses to press charges. The way I see it, she is creating a maniac who thinks he can just hit women and get away with it.

    Yes she feels and is guilty at this point ... (if she let him doing what ever he wants) Well also 32 is a bit old for her to be able to overcome it ... they need specialists !!!

    He ran into the kitchen, and grabbed a heavy bottle, then hit me at the back of the head with it

    And he is dangerous ... what's next ? !!! does she want him to get into a psychic hospital !!!

    Would you lie to 'protect' your partner, even if you knew they were in the wrong ??

    No way ... just because that wouldn't protect him on the long run ... and well one day he might get in trouble with somebody who won't care about who and what he is (or just somebody like him or worse than him).

    they both need help (mother and son)

  • Xena
    Xena

    Sounds like you had a rough time of it Bull!

    It's amazing the lengths mom's will go to sometimes to protect their kids, unfortunately in cases like this it's very misguided. I hope she gets some help for the both of them before something like this happens again.

    Honestly I would have probably done the same as you...you don't mess with my loved ones!

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Honestly?
    I'm a peaceable man, as you know, but I truly believe that I'd have ripped his lungs out and fed them to him as souffle.

    Nobody, but nobody touches my loved ones. I don't ask questions, even later.

    I suspect the parents must take some of the responsibility, however, for tolerating abuse. It was likely only a matter of time before he attacked someone outwith the immediate family circle (be that an aunt or another visitor).

    I don't envy him having been on the receiving end of your ire. Not a wonder he looked scared - LOL.

  • dh
    dh
    How far would you go to protect your partner ?

    there is no limit.

  • Snapdragon
    Snapdragon

    Wow Bull,

    I'm really sorry about this situation. Because its close family the problem is even more difficult to deal with. Very sticky.

    An observation as an American:

    With the astounding things that have happened in our country in the past 10 years I think we all ask how far it has to go before someone does something. Kids who seem depressed or anti-social suddenly go on a killing spree, etc. So as a jumpy American, who thinks you can't EVER be too careful with this crap, I think you should do more. Maybe he'll be wary of you, but is there a possibility that your wife might be on his list?

    If my nephew had hit me, my husband would have handed him his testes on a platter. You only did what any mate would have. Bravo.

    ~Snapdragon

  • Lostreality
    Lostreality

    I dont know.

    Depends on if it will stop the person trying to harm my loved ones. If there is only one thing..well then...somethings gotta be done.

  • doogie
    doogie

    i agree with LT on this.

    i'm not a violent person and believe that violence never solves anything...

    however, if anyone ever touched my girlfriend there would be no limit to how fast and how furious they would get theirs.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit