Didn't Your Disfellowshipping Make you Feel SO Loved?

by Englishman 16 Replies latest jw friends

  • Englishman
    Englishman

    No?

    Well, according to the Sept '96 Awake, this pretending that you don't exist routine is a very loving arrangement!

    The

    Bible?s Viewpoint

    Why

    Disfellowshipping Is a Loving Arrangement

    EXCOMMUNICATION?the very idea stirs up mixed feelings among many religious people. Most people agree that religions need some sort of discipline. But many view excommunication as a relic from the past?a harsh style of discipline that reminds them of witch-hunts and inquisitions.

    Adding to the problem is the pervasive influence of the secular world. Thus, most of Christendom?s religions have adopted a more tolerant view of sin. Little wonder, then, that one Episcopalian minister said: "Excommunication is part of our tradition, but I don?t think it?s been invoked in this century."

    However, many people may be surprised to learn that among Jehovah?s Witnesses, disfellowshipping (the equivalent of excommunication) is taken seriously. Granted, it is not an easy action to take, but it is a loving arrangement. How so?

    It

    Upholds God?s Name

    Jehovah is a holy God. He does not tolerate deliberate sin on the part of those claiming to worship him. The apostle Peter wrote to Christians: "Become holy yourselves in all your conduct, because it is written: ?You must be holy, because I am holy.?" (1 Peter 1:15, 16) So disfellowshipping unrepentant sinners upholds God?s holy name; it shows love for that name.?Compare Hebrews 6:10.

    Does this mean that if a Christian succumbs to weakness or stumbles into grave sin, he is automatically expelled from the congregation? By no means! Jehovah is not a coldhearted dictator. He is merciful and understanding. He remembers that we are imperfect. (Psalm 103:14) Jehovah recognizes that "all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God." (Romans 3:23) God has arranged for spiritual help within the congregation so that if a Christian takes a "false step" or even commits a serious sin, he may be lovingly ?readjusted? in a spirit of mildness. (Galatians 6:1) By accepting counsel from God?s Word and demonstrating heartfelt sorrow and genuine repentance, one who has strayed from the path of righteousness can "get healed" spiritually.?James 5:13-16.

    What, though, if a baptized Christian seriously errs and all efforts to restore him are unsuccessful? In other words, what if he stubbornly refuses to correct his sinful course?

    It

    Keeps the Congregation Safe

    The Bible commands Christians: "Quit mixing in company with anyone called a brother that is a fornicator or a greedy person or an idolater or a reviler or a drunkard or an extortioner, not even eating with such a man."?1 Corinthians 5:11.

    Is this Bible law harsh and demeaning? Just consider this: When a hardened criminal is sent to prison for breaking the law, is that viewed as harsh or coldhearted? No, because the public has the right to safeguard the peace and security of the community. In effect, the criminal is disfellowshipped from law-abiding society during his prison term.

    Similarly, the Christian congregation is justified in expelling unrepentant wrongdoers from their midst. Why? Because the congregation must be a haven from immoral predators and other willful practicers of sin.

    Realizing that "one sinner can destroy much good," the apostle Paul commanded fellow believers: "Remove the wicked man from among yourselves." (Ecclesiastes 9:18; 1 Corinthians 5:13) This action prevents the sinner from spreading corruption in the congregation, and it protects the congregation?s good name.?Compare 1 Timothy 3:15.

    Protection

    for Individuals

    Disfellowshipping also protects individual members of the congregation. Let us illustrate: Imagine being roused from sleep by the noisy blast of a car horn or alarm. The piercing sound is difficult to ignore; indeed, it startles you! Likewise, when someone is expelled from the congregation, the action hopefully grabs the attention of every member of the flock. It disturbs their senses. It cannot be ignored. How may this be a protection?

    "When I first heard at the Kingdom Hall that someone had been disfellowshipped, my initial reaction was shock," says one Witness. "Then it humbled me. It made me realize that I too could fall." As her words indicate, disfellowshipping can move others to take stock of their conduct.?1 Corinthians 10:12.

    By asking ourselves questions such as ?Are there any areas of my life in which I am spiritually vulnerable?? we can be helped to examine our own standing with God. In this way we can continue to ?work out our own salvation with fear and trembling.??Philippians 2:12.

    Return to God

    "As hard as it was," said one Christian who was expelled for a time, "the discipline was necessary and much needed, and it proved to be lifesaving." This highlights another important aspect of disfellowshipping. It can move previously unrepentant sinners to take their first steps back to God.

    The apostle Paul said: "Whom Jehovah loves he disciplines." (Hebrews 12:6) And while it is true that "no discipline seems for the present to be joyous, but grievous; yet afterward to those who have been trained by it it yields peaceable fruit, namely, righteousness."?Hebrews 12:11.

    That is what happened to Richard. After being disfellowshipped for almost two years, he repented, corrected his God-dishonoring conduct, and was accepted back into the Christian congregation. Looking back, he says regarding the experience: "I realize that I had to be disfellowshipped and that I fully deserved what I got. It really was necessary and helped me to see just how serious my course was and the need to seek Jehovah?s forgiveness."

    Discipline may not be easy to endure. Accepting it requires humility, but those who learn from it reap bountiful fruitage.

    Therefore, disfellowshipping is a loving arrangement because it upholds God?s holy name and it protects the congregation from the corrupting influence of sin. Also, it demonstrates love for the wrongdoer by encouraging him to repent and "turn around so as to get [his] sins blotted out, that seasons of refreshing may come from the person of Jehovah."?Acts 3:19.

    [Footnote]

    Excommunication is a disciplinary action that results in exclusion from membership in a religion.

    [Picture Credit Line on page 26]

    The New Testament: A Pictorial Archive from Nineteenth-Century Sources, by Don Rice/Dover Publications, Inc.<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

    Now come on. Doesn't that make you feel better?

    Englishman.

  • Purza
    Purza

    Jehovah is not a coldhearted dictator. He is merciful and understanding. He remembers that we are imperfect.

    What they failed to mention is that the WTBTS are cold hearted dictators and they do remember (daily) that we are imperfect.

    Purza

  • Gopher
    Gopher

    Good one, Mike. No I don't feel better.

    OTOH, disfellowshipping is beneficial (to use a JW-theocratic term) in that it protects ME from having JW's bother me with all their nonsense. It's been a clean break for me, and I now see it as a good thing.

    Is this Bible law harsh and demeaning?

    No. The Bible clearly says a willfully-disobedient person shouldn't be allowed full stature within the congregation. However, the practice of enforced shunning as carried out by Jehovah's Witnesses is a man-made and harsh. It's carried out at the whim of the elders who think they must "judge" repentance. This leads to a lot of emotional and just-plain-wrong decisions.

    ... the congregation must be a haven from immoral predators and other willful practicers of sin.

    Don't make me laugh. There are thousands of "immoral predators" in good standing in the JW organization. www.silentlambs.org

  • MerryMagdalene
    MerryMagdalene

    Yes, actually, my JW family does make sure I knew how much they love me in their own sad, twisted way... "We love you, but you don't love us and you don't love God. We love you even though you are selfish and stubborn and deceived by the devil. We love you even though you are breaking our hearts. Come back to us and you can once again be the shunner rather than the shunned."

    Love you to death, they do.

    I spent way too many years in continual inner conflict because of that kind of love. Thanks but no thanks. They can call it what they like, it's still cruel and unusual.

    My kindest regards to you, Englishman. It is good to be reminded how they twist minds and manipulate hearts so that doing what is naturally good seems frightfully bad and doing what is painfully bad seems righteously good.

  • Netty
    Netty

    Gosh it is all just so twisted. I remember once when I protested to my father about my sister being shunned by them, he said " this is a loving arrangement, it is supposed to shock her into realizing what she has done wrong, and returning to Jehovah"

    Reality? My sister is demoralized, she feels worthless, inferior, has no self worth, self esteem, has lots of psychological issues to do her being shunned and made to feel like a 2nd class citizen by my family.

    Yes, LOVE true LOVE, so nice to see it in action.

  • Preston
    Preston

    I guess using that logic the organization should feel like they are being loved by us for our routine acts of public humiliation of them on this messageboard. Therefore, they shouldn't harbor any grudges from those nasty apostates fon JW.com. Cheers!

  • kwintestal
    kwintestal

    When I felt that big boot hit me on my ass-end, I could feel the love! And when they announced it at the hall followed by a local needs talk regarding "loose conduct", which was my crime, and lumping in smoking and drug use, which I didn't do but they wanted to make ones think I did, I felt like the whole cong. was giving me a giant group hug! That hug made me feel sick more then anything.

    Kwin

  • metatron
    metatron

    In Watchtower-land, Hate is Love

    Slavery is Freedom

    Ignorance is Strength

    metatron

  • Dawn
    Dawn

    Loved?! What a joke! They dont' know what love is.

  • FlyingHighNow
    FlyingHighNow
    It Keeps the Congregation Safe

    Oh give me a break.

    You want to know the sick truth? I was never disfellowshipped and I am treated just like I am by my sister and her family and my youngest brother. She doesn't even call me if someone in her family is seriously ill anymore. I am told by one of her sons that they tell him they HATE me. Yes, that's loving. Yes, it makes me feel luh uh uh uh uhved! Can't you tell???

    Heather

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit