Were they right about anything?

by kwintestal 23 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • LittleToe
    LittleToe

    Wizedup:
    Glad to hear you both saw the light.
    I just noticed you today.
    Welcome to the board!

    Gumby:
    Ya ole b*st*rd!!!
    You know I'm taller than Shotgun, and the dude in the pic hasn't got a beard, either!

    Kwin:
    No - I can't think of a single thing they got right.
    Regarding their doctrines, I can't think of anything there, either.
    Even where it seems close to mainstream Christian it's still not Christ-centered, so it's subtly corrupt.

  • ozziepost
    ozziepost
    Even where it seems close to mainstream Christian it's still not Christ-centered, so it's subtly corrupt.

    Ain't that the truth!

    I suspect there are a few nuances of bible understanding that may, just may, be correct but they are preipheral at best.

  • ThisGuy04
    ThisGuy04

    here's one that my dad always likes to bring up...blood. they were right about blood.

    he'll say "even back when we were ridiculed and laughed at for not taking blood, we stood by our beliefs, even when we didn't really know why. and NOW, well just look at it! with all of the tainted blood, the currupt red cross. there are even all kinds of studies out there from non-jw sources that say blood in surgery actually *slows down* recovery and success rates. there are even hospitals were they try to do the majority of their surgeries *without* blood!" and he'll go on and bust out some books or papers that show he's correct. now, he is on the blood liaison committee, so i'm sure that's where he gets all of his 'inside info'

    i realize this isn't a prophecy or whatever, but just wondering what some rebuttals or other thoughts on the matter would be...?

    i'm a newbie, so i apologize if this has been gone over on other posts

  • kwintestal
    kwintestal
    there are even all kinds of studies out there from non-jw sources that say blood in surgery actually *slows down* recovery and success rates. there are even hospitals were they try to do the majority of their surgeries *without* blood!" and he'll go on and bust out some books or papers that show he's correct.

    Welcome to the forum ThisGuy04

    I wonder how many studies show the exact opposite of what these studies showed? Sure, we've had problems with blood in the past (tainted blood scandal), but there are several medical "solutions" that have had equally bad or worse problems for the ill person. These have been taken off the market or the problem has been resolved.

    Screening of blood in Canada is very thorough that now the risks are very low.

    Kwin

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit