The Christmas Spirit, According to Scrooge

by Leolaia 14 Replies latest jw friends

  • Leolaia
    Leolaia

    *** w54 12/15 pp. 739-740 What Is This Christmas Spirit? ***

    What

    Is This Christmas Spirit?

    WHAT is it that men call "the beautiful spirit of Christmas"? Is it a crowded department store, charged with emotion, packed with excitement, loaded with gadgets and glimmering with inflated "cut-rate" prices? Is it the electrified commotion of mobs surging through the streets, the frenzy to board overcrowded buses, the dash to squeeze in crammed subways or the honks of automobiles snarled in endless traffic jams? Is it haggard-looking women with their arms full of gaily wrapped bundles and their hands full of children? Or is it the resigned husband who condescends but wishes it were not so?

    What is this spirit of Christmas? Is it the carillon at Sts. Peter and Paul, filling the gray morning air with the timeless chimes of tradition? Is it the choral concerts and organ music and the tinkling of noisy bells? Or is it the blaring of a thousand jukeboxes ringing out the cynical sentiments of "Santa, Baby"?

    What is this Christmas spirit? Is it the Salvation Army musicians marching from corner to corner reminding passersby that it is more blessed to give? Is it a legless man in front of Hotel Ritz selling pencils on a cold sidewalk waving a "merry Christmas" to prospective customers as they step out of their long shiny limousines? Is it the wreath at the entrance of Pearl Street flophouse, with a sign on it that says, "Please do not steal this"?

    Is this the Christmas spirit? An exhausted elevator operator at Mixie?s dress shop hoping for a generous bonus that she will never get? A huge diamond ring or a pearl necklace being fondled by Mabel with cold, avaricious lust? A loud necktie that Dad will never wear?

    What is this Christmas spirit? Is it a week?s vacation, a respite from work, an escape from school, a breath of country air, a moment with family, a word with friends, a retreat to quiet solitude? Is it a table covered with candy and nuts, gingerbread and mince pie, a roast pig or fried chicken? Is it a cocktail party with loud music, the making up of a big batch of eggnog for uninvited guests, or becoming "good and drunk" or licentious, or that of being "a jolly good fellow"?

    What is this spirit of Christmas? Is it junior staring transfixed at an electric train as it spins in crazy circles, or sister cuddling her tiny doll that says "Mommie"? Is it the feverish search for the right gift that cannot be found, the evergrowing anticipation in the eyes of the young that want toys but cannot read price tags? Is it the endless chain of Christmas cards that flutter across the desk on their way to the wastebasket? Is it the Christmas tree covered with artificial snow and laden with colored bulbs that tell of pagan star gods? Is it the candles that chase away the evil spirits, the mistletoe that commemorates superstitious legends, or the yule log that repeats a pagan lie?

    Just what is this spirit of Christmas? Is it the spirit of God and Christ? Is it the spirit that proclaims "peace on earth, good will toward men"? Is it the spirit that magnifies the great God of the universe? Or does this spirit defame and abominate the pure worship of God? "Beloved ones," said the apostle John, "do not believe every inspired expression ["spirit," footnote], but test the inspired expressions [spirits] to see whether they originate with God." "Make sure of all things," urged Paul, "hold fast to what is right. Keep yourselves free from every form of wickedness."?1 John 4:1; 1 Thess. 5:21, 22, NW.

  • little witch
    little witch

    Quite simply, Christmas is a Christian Holiday celebrating the Joy of Our Mighty Savior Come To Earth. It is a celebration of peace and love to all humankind.

    Some folks evidently have a problem with peace and love and well wishes,...... jw's are amoung them. To them and their kind I continue to wish peace and love, and forgive them their hostility....That is and will be the real meaning of christmas....

  • Country_Woman
  • frankiespeakin
    frankiespeakin

    The Wt's take on it is if it don't worship jehovah it ain't no good:

    Just what is this spirit of Christmas? Is it the spirit of God and Christ? Is it the spirit that proclaims "peace on earth, good will toward men"? Is it the spirit that magnifies the great God of the universe? Or does this spirit defame and abominate the pure worship of God? "Beloved ones," said the apostle John, "do not believe every inspired expression ["spirit," footnote], but test the inspired expressions [spirits] to see whether they originate with God." "Make sure of all things," urged Paul, "hold fast to what is right. Keep yourselves free from every form of wickedness."?1 John 4:1; 1 Thess. 5:21, 22, NW.

    And of course they give it a sense of urgency by quoting scripture,,and subtly bring in the idea without comeing right out and saying it,,,that celibrating christmas is a form of wickedness.

    The timing of these article on christmas always seems to be in december. Surely they do not have the general public in mind,,for such articles would not be very appealing that time of year,,and highly controversial. These articles that are placed door to door are really intended for the rank and file to keep them "seperate from the world" and in the control of the WT.

  • Narkissos
    Narkissos

    Well... the "WT spirit" is lamentable as ever, but am I mistaken in thinking that those 50's articles were better written than those I could read in the 70's-80's?

  • Happy Guy :)
    Happy Guy :)

    It's articles like this that make me think that the writers at the WT are mental cases.

  • Leolaia
    Leolaia

    The article does have a poetic ring to it....I suspect it was done in conscious imitation of those semi-poetic "Meaning of Christmas" editorials that appear in newspapers on Christmas morning. I thought it was amazing how the article characterizes Christmas in such hideous, cold terms. If we knew nothing about the holiday except what is printed here, we would think that Christmas is a day for which --

    • People stampede in commotion into traffic jams, mobs on the streets and crowded subways,
    • And lust after diamond rings and pearl necklaces,
    • Legless, handicapped men in wheelchairs struggle to sell pencils,
    • People become drunk or licentious,
    • Homeless people become inclined to steal things at the shelter,
    • People selfishly, greedily anticipate material things,
    • Boys mindlessly stare at toy trains going in circles and girls clutch talking dolls,
    • People wastefully exchange greeting cards destined for the trash,
    • And people defame and abominate God, and decorate their houses with symbolic ornaments that repeat pagan lies.

    What a bleak and grotesque portrait of a day filled with love, family, and wishes for peace. And the article ends on a laughable note, construing the "Christmas spirit" in terms of the literal demonic "spirits" mentioned in 1 John.

  • willyloman
    willyloman
    huge diamond ring or a pearl necklace being fondled by Mabel with cold, avaricious lust?

    That Mabel... She's a crackup.

    Somehow this '54 WT article reminded me of a talk that was making the rounds on cassette tape back in the mid-1970's. It was the famous Brother Kite and his "What Would Jesus Think of Christmas?" He had Jesus standing at a crowded corner in a big city during the holidays and challenging the crowd as to what they thought they were doing. Anybody remember that?

  • Leolaia
    Leolaia

    willyloman....I think this is the anti-Christmas sermon...

    ***

    w56 12/15 p. 743 What Would Jesus Say? ***

    IMAGINE, if you will, Jesus walking down the gaily bedecked and brightly lighted streets of one of Christendom?s major cities. It is Christmas time. The town Christmas tree blazes in resplendent glory. Santa Clauses seem to be everywhere. And so do the shoppers. They are dashing in droves to department stores to make last-minute purchases. From loudspeakers blare Christmas carols interspersed with blatant commercials. Cash registers add their financially satisfying song to the din. A "Merry Christmas" slides off active tongues. The Christmas spirit has reached a high pitch. Amid all the commotion Jesus inquires of a celebrant about the meaning of all this unusual bustle.

    "Oh," comes the reply, "this is Christmas, the greatest birthday party of the year." "But," asks Jesus, "whose birthday is it?"

    Whose birthday is it? A strange question? Not really. A newcomer to Christendom would truly wonder. After all, does the furious exchange of gifts identify the one in whose honor the celebration is being held? Do the millions of dollars of advertising tell whose birthday is being celebrated? Do the lavish displays in store windows, the decorated Christmas trees or the colored lights strung in the streets tell whose birthday it is? And Santa Claus, the great central figure in millions of homes, who symbolizes this celebration as no other character does, fails to enlighten the stranger as to whose birthday it is.

    Not strange, then, that Jesus would ask the celebrant: "Whose birthday is it?" "Oh," comes the answer, "it?s December 25, Christ?s birthday." Now what would Jesus say? That not only does the celebration fail to honor the Son of God but the date is all wrong. Referring to the Bible record, Jesus could show that he was not born in December at all. How so? Because the Bible shows he was born on or about October 1, 2 B.C., that he came as Messiah A.D. 29 and was put to death three and a half years later, or about April 1, A.D. 33.

    Now what would Jesus say about Christendom?s religions? taking part in a hoax and leading people to believe he was born on December 25? He would point to the prophecy made by one of his apostles: "There will be a period of time when they will not put up with the healthful teaching, but, in accord with their own desires, they will accumulate teachers for themselves to have their ears tickled, and they will turn their ears away from the truth, whereas they will be turned aside to false stories."?2 Tim. 4:3, 4, NW.

    Like the Israelites who tolerated religious falsehoods and abominations for what selfish gain they could derive from false stories, so are the Christmas celebrants who not only tolerate but prefer the hoax of Christ?s birthday party. So well might Jesus point to the words of Jehovah: "An awful and appalling thing has happened in the land: the prophets prophesy by false gods, and the priests make profit through them; my people love to have it so."?Jer. 5:30, 31, AT.

    What would Jesus say to those professed Christians who try to justify Christmas in spite of its false date and pagan background? He would say that he never commanded it, that his birthday was never celebrated by any of his apostles or early disciples, that it was only after the foretold apostasy that the Christmas celebration came into existence among professed Christians. This apostasy was foretold by Christ?s apostle, who said that it would result in "twisted things.".... And what would Jesus say of all the prominence given to "three" wise men on Christmas cards and decorations? He would ask why all the honor is given them, for the wise men were astrologers or demon worshipers....

    What would Jesus say of the endless portrayal of him as an infant? He would say that he no longer is an infant, so why cause people to think of him as a babe? Viewing Jesus only as a babe is dangerous. It diverts one from the vital fact that he has been empowered by his Father as King and that he now reigns and will shortly smash all nations with a rod of iron as he "carries on war in righteousness." Should a world-smashing King, indeed, the "King of kings and Lord of lords," be thought of as a babe? Thus the focusing of the people?s attention on Jesus as an infant is a deception, a deception perpetrated by that master Deceiver, Satan the Devil.?Rev. 19:11-16, NW.

    And what would Jesus say of the Christmas celebrants themselves? Does their conduct honor Christ? In one sweeping statement Jesus could answer, quoting the prophecy concerning the "last days" in which there will be "lovers of pleasures rather than lovers of God." Christmas time spawns an overabundance of these. Not only that but at Christmas time many celebrants, like the ancient pagans, hurtle into the sullied seas of overdrinking, overeating and immorality....Just what would Jesus say of the Christmas customs, the use of holly, mistletoe, Yule logs and Christmas trees? He would state the candid facts, just as the encyclopedias do: that such customs are not Christian practices but are of heathen origin.

    What would Jesus say about giving presents? Certainly Jesus would not condemn giving; he commended it as a source of happiness. Yet the exchanging of gifts, as it is done at Christmas, would not receive Jesus? approval, for the giving is patterned after the exchanging of gifts during the pagan Saturnalia. Also, most Christmas giving is done on a reciprocal basis; Christ said to give to those who cannot repay you. And the Bible does not, as some think, set the pattern for gift exchanging. Who brought gifts to Jesus? None other than the demon-worshiping astrologers! Certainly Christians are not to follow their example.

    And what would Jesus say of teeming celebrants whose excitement does not conceal their ignorance, their lack of knowledge of the kingdom that Christ preached as the hope of the world? He would say that the people are too busy to learn the way to life and Christmas only makes them that much busier....Nothing wrong with these pursuits, but the trouble is people busy themselves so deeply in them, especially at Christmas time, eating, drinking and buying, that they have no room in their lives for knowledge of God?s purposes through his Son. And so ignorance of the oncoming war of Armageddon and of the incoming new world remains widespread.

    So what would Christ say of Christmas? That Christmas is a religious hoax, a commercial trap, a pagan holiday, a dishonor to him and a degrading of Christianity. He could never approve it; he could never recognize it as a true Christian practice. That means that those who celebrate it come under Christ?s disapproval. That being the case, why celebrate Christmas? Why not be free of this colossal commercial snare? No need to celebrate because other professed Christians do! Indeed, there is no need to be among those teeming professed Christians whom, despite their protests of doing works in Christ?s name, the King refuses to recognize:

    "Many will say to me in that day: ?Master, Master, did we not prophesy in your name, and expel demons in your name, and perform many powerful works in your name?? And yet then I will confess to them: I never knew you at all. Get away from me, you workers of lawlessness." So that you never have to get away from Christ then, get away from Christmas now.?Matt. 7:22, 23, NW.

  • Kaethra
    Kaethra

    The sad thing is that that kind of article is exactly what has shaped the thinking of most dubs, at least those of the older generation. They need to see Christmas as being this ugly thing to be loathed...that there is absolutely nothing redeeming about it. I think it's envy for what they can't have.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit