Interesting (at least it was to me...)

by robhic 11 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • robhic
    robhic

    Yesterday I answered a knock on the door and found 2 well-dressed men who were obviously JWs. They told me they were in the neighborhood and wanted to share some scriptures with me. OK, I've heard that little smoke screen before. But then they asked if I was familiar with jehovah's witnesses -- that was a new tack for them to take. Not the "Christian group wanting to share this or that" but they actually admitted they were JWs. Is this a new thing?

    Anyway, I replied that yes I was because I was involved with a woman who had become a JW. So they repeated the request to share some scriptures with me. I said "sure, as long as I can pick the scripture." They missed a beat but then said "What scripture would you like to discuss?"

    I told them I really would like them to point out in the bible where it says Jesus came back invisibly in 1914. Hmm, a little bit of surprise and they said that that would take more than just one scripture to prove and it would take too long without an in-depth bible-study. I said why should it? Just point out one of the scriptures pertinent to the 1914 invisible return of Christ. It should be easy since it's a central doctrine.

    They asked me where I had obtained this knowledge. I told them from books, reading the bible and people they would probably label "apostates." They didn't seem (at least outwardly) as concerned as I'd expected but again danced around my request.

    I said, "OK, how 'bout the one were heaven's doors were supposed to be closed in 1935?" They flat-out denied that one and turned the conversation towards how I felt about the bible and god, hisself.

    I told 'em I was leaning towards being agnostic because I had a problem with the bible as more than a collection of tales, fables and instruction that is 2000 years out of date. They tried to show me the good advice available and used the scripture about all scripture being good for "teaching, reproving, etc." I countered with the fact that cloven-hooved animals and some that swim were forbidden but that I found great delight in eating seafood and pork poroducts.

    They allowed Leviticus was maybe not so relevant today but tried to again show me how the bible was the word of god. I told them I didn't have the greatest opinion of such a woman-hating, violent killer, plus I didn't like any organized religions, even the catholic one in which I was raised.

    Why is the commandment to not covet thy neighbor's wife and not spouse? Seemed quite mysoginistic to me. Women were considered property and I didn't hold with that belief. They countered with something from Paul (how ironic was that?) and I countered with the one where the women were forbidden to speak in the congregations and that I thought that was bullshit, too!

    We danced around a little more and then they started on the 144,000 and I asked if it was literal or figurative. They said it was a literal number. So I said then they would be unmarried, Jewish virgin men only. They said no that was figurative and I said they couldn't switch back and forth and either 144,000 Jewish virgin men made up this group or then the number could be much more than 144K. What was it?

    Another side step and then they started on revelations and asked me about the cryptic nature of revelations. I said that, for my money, John of Patmos was probably using substances that would be classified as illegal today. At that they smiled, chuckled and said they would use that as the point to stop our discussion .... for today. Does that mean I'll get a return visit? I really want a chance to trot out the timeline from "Alleymom" where she blows the 607 date out of the water. This could be fun.

  • Lostreality
    Lostreality

    woot, return visits rox0rs my b0x0rs!

  • Quotes
    Quotes

    I'll bet...

    ... they will *NOT* be back.

    Even if you are not marked it their territory record cards as "opposer lives here", then at the very least, they will conclude that you represent a lot of work and don't have the right "heart condition" and are not worthy of a return visit.

    The next time the territory is worked (say, 6 to 36 months from now) you will have the exact same conversation with the who calls then. Even if it is the same two people, they wil have completely ignored and forgotten their previous visit. If that is the case, it might be fun to start by pointing out they are not doing their job very well: "Hey, after you las visit two years ago (!!!) I thought you were coming back soon to discuss some more things?"

    ~Quotes

  • Honesty
    Honesty

    And, trotting away, rejoiced that they had been persecuted for bearing witness about Jesus..... NOT.

  • GetBusyLiving
    GetBusyLiving

    :Even if you are not marked it their territory record cards as "opposer lives here", then at the very least, they will conclude that you represent a lot of work and don't have the right "heart condition"


    They don't like having to think too much. The status quo and happy thoughts are much better.

  • clementine
    clementine

    just as quotes, i would bet they won't come back... you are a problem for us as you do not answer the way they're used to (and the way they had been learnt). maybe they take you for an apostate also ;-) anyway, that must have been a great visit :-)) !!

  • clementine
    clementine

    forgot to say... :-)) that's strange they asked you if you were familiar with JWs... i didn't know they did that... they came once at home and i told them i was familiar with some JWs but they had not asked me that before, i told that on my own... well, i find funny they told you this!

  • Biogret
    Biogret

    blah blah blah, let me show you a book called "101 Questions to ask your JW" You are not the first one to go "Hey! I was smart today when the JW's showed up, I asked questions that they just couldn't answer in a simple 2 sentence response! Me so smart, me so ed-u-cated! >>>>told them I really would like them to point out in the bible where it says Jesus came back invisibly in 1914. Hmm, a little bit of surprise and they said that that would take more than just one scripture to prove and it would take too long without an in-depth bible-study. I said why should it? Just point out one of the scriptures pertinent to the 1914 invisible return of Christ. It should be easy since it's a central doctrine.

  • Biogret
    Biogret

    Really huh, should be easy since its a central doctrine? You may not believe in the Catholic church you grew up in, but guess what they would have said if you would have asked for a simple answer on the Trinity? I'll give you a little hint, since I have asked many. They say something along the lines of "Oh, its too complicated for mere man to understand, and if you ask, you must not have faith in God" Now, let me ask you this, if you needed to reformat your HD, install Win 98, install your video card, soundcard, network card, hook up the internet, and reinstall all your software programs.. you think someone could pick out one or two paragraphs out of a book on this subject to help you? Didn't think so, next time, skip that argument, and come up with a new one. one other point. "Another side step and then they started on revelations and asked me about the cryptic nature of revelations. I said that, for my money, John of Patmos was probably using substances that would be classified as illegal today. At that they smiled, chuckled and said they would use that as the point to stop our discussion .... for today. Does that mean I'll get a return visit? I really want a chance to trot out the timeline from "Alleymom" where she blows the 607 date out of the water. This could be fun" Next time, INVITE them back for a return visit, ask as many questions as you like, TAPE it, because when I did this, after listening to many ppl say "hey! ask your JW this!" type of stupid posts, you know what I found out? That their arguments make alot more sense then yours. Not one of them said, "and that I thought that was bullshit, too! "

  • pr_capone
    pr_capone

    Bio... ok bud. We all have plenty of time and plenty of scholars of our own. Bring out your discussions and we will be more than happy to hammer some thoughts back and forth with you.

    At the VERY LEAST, they could have hit the 144,000 without blinking. I know I used to be able to when I was a pioneer.

    The thing that scares witnesses the most, aside from being df'd, is a knowledgable "householder".

    You have the floor.

    Kansas District Overbeer

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit