Hi Scotsman!
I don't think the ID scheme is perfect. I'm sure there will be flaws in it as in any system. I believe the centralising of information is what's important.
After 9/11 and the police and securtity services began concentrating on serious terrorism I wondered if the petty criminals would begin to take advantage of police being stretched to the limit. And they did.
Why do I hope it would help with the problems in my area? I hope, and as I said I don't expect it to be perfect, but I hope that it will give police time to get back to the streets to some extent. They can find out at the press of a button everything about a person they're holding. And maybe they will manage to fish out some terrorist, maybe serial offenders and even the petty yobs.
The Yorkshire Ripper escaped justice and killed many more times because his information was not computerised and centralised.
Up the road from us last weekend a girl was brutally beaten up by a gang and the police did not attend the incident until the next day because they had NO officers and there was TOO many other serious assaults and incidents that Friday night. We need more police and the ones we have need more free time and instant access to information on suspects.
I know Edingburgh is a pretty reasonable city to walk through come and evening and maybe difficult for you to understand what we see here every day, but we live in a NICE neighbourhood. It's turning very NOT NICE.
I hope the ID cards will help. As I said I can see the drawbacks, especially when technology goes wrong but...we need to know who's who, and we need to free up and assist the police.
Everything can be abused by someone who wants to abuse a system, but that doesn't mean we don't use the technology to protect Mrs Little Old Lady next door who is too scared to go and buy a pint of milk in the evening and right to be scared too, sadly.