Wow, you all seem to have a lot of good stories to tell about liver.
Yes, it really is all about how liver is cooked. It must be cooked very quickly on a very high, searing heat, for about 3 or 4 minutes. (Some do it in about 2 minutes, but that is way too rare for me, and you see the blood running all over your plate when it's that rare.)
High heat for a short time = very tender liver, with a wonderful flavour.
Frying for 7 or 8 minutes or longer = Shoe Leather and a very unpleasant experience.
I don't really like liver all by itself. There is definitely something missing if you don't eat each tender morsel with some bacon and fried onions, mixed with some nice brown gravy. That rounds out the flavour. I think liver was meant to be eaten with something, not all by itself, and that's why I think some of you may have been turned off liver when you were younger.
There is a fantastic liver recipe that I am going to try and find, where you mix up the onions and bacon with flour and water, plus some gravy type flavouring, which gives it a thick consistency, something like mushroom soup out of a can. Then you put strips of liver in a casserole dish and pour this "sauce" over the liver, and bake it in the oven. Absolutely divine, and it takes away some of that strong taste than many people dislike. I'll get back to you all on this one.
One of the best chicken liver dishes I ever had was from a Chinese restaurant.
I also love liver pate on bread or ritz cracker during party time.
I also discovered I just don't like duck liver, even though it is served in fancy restaurants as an expensive delicacy.
One thing that bothers me about organ meats. Apparently when the animal goes to the slaughter house, they are led down this long narrow corral in single file, and at the front of the line each animal is hit over the head with a huge mallot (to stun it), after which they come and slice off the head. (I suppose that makes it more painless and merciful.) But can you imagine the sheer terror the animals waiting in line must feel? Seeing their "brothers and sisters" being knocked off like that!
Anyway, I have read comments that when an animal experiences fear and terror, this releases a lot of toxins into their blood stream, which then gets concentrated in the organs like liver. Therefore, we would be eating the meat that has the most toxins. I just don't know whether there is any truth to this, but I do wonder about it!
Rod P.