hey Path, again,
Just read the posts: A fine discussion, with Weavis, the moderator, just keeping the threads within the framework of the discussion, not interferring with the though process. One of the best threads I've read, period.
Robbie made excellent insights, imo. When I was reading, I couldn't help but put local personalities from my KH onto some of the posters.
We all know the types: "Have you been spending time with worldling associates instead of your spiritual brothers? You say your conscience allows you this freedom? Perhaps your conscience is not properly trained."
"We have so many new brothers - we need to build another, bigger, Kingdom Hall - proof of Jehovah's spirit upon us." "Many of our Friends are no longer among us - proof that Jehovah is sifting the weeds from the wheat."
"The Friends are being drawn away the path of destruction through various roads - the Internet is the main one Satan is using against young, impressionable brothers at this time." This is a direct quote from our PO on the stage at our Circuit Assembly in the spring of this year. Every PO interviewed (4) said the exact same thing - the internet is the main, most powerful, tool being used by Satan do lure brothers from The Truth.
Man of True God sounds like a pretty straight elder to me - if he's that grounded in real person, he'd be a neat elder. An exception, imo, nonetheless.
When I read COC, I thought the same thing - perhaps Franz is coloring his comments to make himself, and his spirituality, to look more convincing. However, upon more reading, even on witnet, and my own personal experience with the WTBTS's Service & Legal Departments, Franz comes across like the rest of us - just more eloquently.
Per Robbie over at witnet:
What has brought this on? A couple of things stand out. I know there have been other discussions on this board over whether or not there have been failures in the prophecies of the Faithful and Discrete Slave. I'm quite familiar with the language we use to deal with this, the "expectations" that failed to realize, the "over eagerness" we have for prophecies to be fulfilled. But as a teacher in the congregation for several decades, I have absolutely no question in my mind but that the Society has presented numerous ideas and prophecies in the literature over the years that have failed. That is one factor in the changes taking place. Many of us are wondering why an organization directed by God could have made so many mistakes.
The ensuing discussion, whether the WTBTS - as a whole Governing Body - constitutes the same governing position as David, as King, is really interesting. David was rebuked, even severely punished, promptly after he had sinned. And what David did was a despicable sin.
I don't know if failed "prophet-like" prophecies constitutes sin. I don't think the WTBTS set out to deceive their followers, even the world. They just didn't get it right - perhaps for a variety of reasons. But did Jehovah severely punish them individually as He did David? No.
When Paul rebuked Peter for not eating with Gentiles, did Paul get thrown out? Did Peter get thrown out? No. Why was Franz thrown out for not agreeing with the Governing Body - he was a member of the Governing Body? Aren't they all spirit anointed?
Btw, shouldn't any of the Anointed 144,000 Remnant have the same power, insight, spiritual ability as the dozen or so men in Brooklyn? There is a definite inequality of power among equal spirit anointed persons in the WTBTS. As always, particularily if one of the spirit anointed 144,000 Remnant is a woman - still gotta use that Kleenex for a head covering.
Thanks for bring witnet's thread over here.
waiting
Edited by - waiting on 9 September 2000 10:32:39