To start off, I'm not sure if what I have to say is a question or a comment. I disassociated myself at the end of January. It was announced 2 weeks ago. I am being shunned by my blood sister, her husband, inlaws, and my friends here (a truly pitiful number that I would consider "true" friends). I have a 'worldly' boyfriend, one whom I started seeing last August. By then I was already 'gone' in my heart, I just hadn't made it official. Part of that was from fear of shunning, which I knew would happen, and like most other bad things in life, I was actively ignoring/putting off. The other part was because I hadn't reconciled myself in my heart to having broken my vow to Jehovah to serve him 'wholeheartedly'. When I had and when living the so-called "double life" became too much, as well as a healthy dose of pushing from my sis, I finally made it official. I've felt relieved ever since.
So all that being said, I chose to disassociate myself. During my time as a JW, I always understood DA to be the road taken when someone had done wrong but wanted out before they got caught. I didn't really see a difference between DFd and DAd from a 'sin' point of view (which is, essentially how the WTBTS wants is apparently). Now I do understand a difference, that a person can choose to fade or to DA and have done nothing wrong. Understanding, however doesn't make me feel settled.
How can I be classified as 'bad' or 'wrong', when I didn't do anything 'wrong' that was at the level of serious sin? I dated outside the faith, which, to my knowledge, is not grounds for disfellowshipping. Yet I am shunned the same way an 'unrepentant sinner' is. (And please understand, I'm not speaking out of the words of my own heart, as it were, but from the point of view of the JWs.) I'm having trouble grasping that the same course of treatment is handled for both. What about people who just want to leave the religion 'just because'? There's nothing they've 'done', they just don't want to do it anymore. I mean other religions, you can leave and are not shunned.
I guess maybe this isn't a question, since I already know that answer. That it's their defect, their attitude problem, part of the cult mentality, and control. I guess it is just hitting me that shunning really is a completely unloving and uncaring act. I was reading on a new person's post and the comments came up from someone about how it is Pavlovian response and an act of self-righteousness and superior piety (I may not have the exact words, going by memory, but I hope I have the gist). It makes sense to me. I guess I just feel really unsettled.
And I really miss my sister.