Are your office mates arguing that killing Job's family was justified? Saying, in effect, that the means justify the ends.
At first yes, but then when I gave the example of me killing someone family and then replacing them with a better family is that OK. Why is it OK for God to do something but wrong for me to do it. We're suppose to imitate God right? They didn't know what to say to that. It actually made them think.
I'm not sure where this conversation is heading and I'm not even trying to make a point or change anyone's belief. I just brought the question up and I'll let them think about it.