i know communism would and will PROBABLY not work.
Well, based on it's track record, it HASN'T worked, so trying to resurrect it seems pretty futile. Castro's pretty much the last communist stronghold...and I hardly think you'd call the poverty stricken nation led by a brutal dictator, a success.
but there were societies were it worked pretty well. indians, tahiti, aborigines etc. it seems we as europeans are trained to need possessions. this is not necessarily the a principle of nature though.
Yes, society does evolve, doesn't it. The naked facts are that in industrialized, western nations people have a much higher quality of life, have a much higher life expectancy, mortality and morbidity among infants is astronomically lower than that of other more primitive cultures, healthcare vastly superior, the list goes on.
Posessions have ALWAYS been important to people. As you yourself claimed, most worse are fought over "econmics," translated: posessions. Over land (i.e., look at Israeli/Palistine conflict). What's that about? LAND.
Like it or no, communism doesn't work in modern day society, if it ever worked. The cultures you reference are based on a highly religious, structured model, where the Shaman, the spiritual leader, is the driving force. Communism, which is generally premised on the non-existence of religion and God, is devoid of this spiritual drive. For true communism to exist, in the form you suggest it, there must be a SPIRITUAL/RELIGIOUS driving force--a COMMUNITY force that glues all members. Just distributing all the "wealth" devoid of any spiritual or religious reason for doing so, is bound to fail.
Having lived in Europe and studied a bit about other cultures, the best life is one where we can achieve whereever our dreams drive us. Provide for our family, and hopefully, reach out to make other's lives better as well. That is why industrialized nations have longer life expectancy, better health, lower mortality, and can look beyond just bear subsistance to something higher.
I guarantee you that people in non-industrialized, western cultures are not sitting here discussing this. They are just trying to survive.