Posts by slimboyfat

46

the pope has died

by stan livedeath in

most people on the planet have heard of the pope.. most people on the planet have never heard of the governing body..

slimboyfat

vienne I’d be interested to hear more about Rutherford being behind the increased emphasis on Jehovah’s name.

As I understand it Franz was influential in the writing department from as early as 1928. Franz authored the preface to the 1950 NWT and was presumably responsible for the adoption of Jehovah in the NT and for making the argument for its originality in the NT documents.

He was into music and was presumably supportive of the restoration of music to JW meetings shortly after Rutherford died.

He wrote a large proportion of WT books in the middle of the 20th century, including in all likelihood Babylon the Great Has Fallen, Let You Name Be Sanctified, Life Everlasting in the Freedom of the Sons of God, among others. He promoted typology, political neutrality, the blood doctrine, as well as other niche interpretive obsessions.

Altogether I reckon Franz had a huge impact on the history and development of JWs. 1975 was obviously a huge mistake and whether that clouds everything else is a judgement call. A JW might argue that there were kings in Israel who did a lot of bad things but are also remembered for their good deeds and their part in the working out of God’s purpose. Even taking 1975 into account, I think a good case could be made that JWs are unlikely to be as numerous as they are in 2025 had it not been for the intellectual and organisational energy of the Franz/Knorr team in middle decades of the 20th century. And if you think JWs are in some sense being used by God then his impact was net positive.

6

202504April21Announcement!

by Atlantis in

jw
friends

2025**04**april**21**announcement.

.

https://app.filemail.com/d/qpxvufhubdjrdoy .

slimboyfat

Thanks Atlantis, you are doing a great job 👍

Many of these announcements are pretty boring but now an then something interesting gets thrown up

46

the pope has died

by stan livedeath in

most people on the planet have heard of the pope.. most people on the planet have never heard of the governing body..

slimboyfat

But he [Fred Franz] led the Witness faith into false expectations. If not a member of the Governing Body, he'd have been brought before a committee and left in disgrace.

Without Fred Franz there probably wouldn’t have been 1975. But there probably wouldn’t have been the NWT or emphasis on the divine name either. He supported Nathan Knorr who was the genius behind JW literature production, methods of preaching and their impressive postwar growth. I don’t know WT would be half the size without him or what direction they would have gone.

Witnesses come close to worship when he's mentioned.

A few older ones perhaps still feel this way, but I suspect the many JWs wouldn’t even recognise the name these days. Around three quarters of current JWs have been baptised since Franz died and many have probably missed the few references to him in magazines and videos and not appreciated his significance.

14

Narcissist challenges culture ingrained with the concept of “saving face” to perform humiliating retreat

by slimboyfat in

oh yeah, this is going to end well.

hold on to your seats, folks, we’re on the front row of history for, as the chinese might say, “interesting times”.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c8rgkkl7v8lo.

slimboyfat

14

Narcissist challenges culture ingrained with the concept of “saving face” to perform humiliating retreat

by slimboyfat in

oh yeah, this is going to end well.

hold on to your seats, folks, we’re on the front row of history for, as the chinese might say, “interesting times”.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c8rgkkl7v8lo.

slimboyfat

3

Our (JW) genetic mutation

by Jalisco in

the spiritual dna of our faith was "protestant" for over 100 years, until 1985, after which it changed to a catholic sense.

for example, for decades we were presented with the example of the bereans who "were more noble-minded than those of thessalonica" because they went to see in the scriptures if what paul preached to them was really like that.

and then a second to the bereans?

slimboyfat

Interesting post. The change in wording of the baptismal questions you highlight is significant, but I don’t know it can bear the weight of an entire pivot from Protestant to Catholic ethos you outline. For example, the phrase “the Society” rose to prominence already under Rutherford, and functioned somewhat like a Catholic appeal to authority. This linguistic process is documented, and much lamented, in Timothy White’s book A People for his Name. A similarity in structure between the Watchtower organisation and the Catholic Church, especially following the restructuring in the early 1970s, was also already noted in graphic form by Penton and others in the 1980s.

From a certain perspective, especially for anyone familiar with the Christadelphian tradition, and to a certain extent Brethren and Presbyterian traditions, one of the remarkable aspects of Watchtower history, especially since the 1930s, has been the striking lack of divisions and splits that chronically plague those other groups. How do we account for that? Surely lots of factors are involved but the centralisation of authority and the “faithful and discreet slave” teaching are surely essential ingredients.

I very much agree with you (I think) that it would be great if JWs could move to a position of accepting differences of opinion and interpretation to a (far) greater extent than they currently do. Whether this sweet spot can be achieved that you hint at, whereby a Catholic approach to diversity may allow differences to flourish without the Protestant penchant for it resulting in divisions and splits, I do not know. I do know that when divisions on matters of doctrine and policy begin to take hold among a faith group it can become chronic, debilitating, and exhausting for all involved. That is something JWs have never had to contend with, indeed it’s so far outside the JW experience that complacency may make it appear in some sense impossible. But if you open the door to greater variability of belief and practice it might open a door to something that is both unfamiliar and not easy to contend with. I don’t say this makes it not worth doing, but if so it would preferably be with eyes wide open to the challenges and possible consequences.

14

Narcissist challenges culture ingrained with the concept of “saving face” to perform humiliating retreat

by slimboyfat in

oh yeah, this is going to end well.

hold on to your seats, folks, we’re on the front row of history for, as the chinese might say, “interesting times”.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c8rgkkl7v8lo.

slimboyfat

I think Trump is picking on the wrong people here. If any country has the ability to stand their ground it’s China. They can just sell their goods elsewhere. America may be the largest economy, but it’s in relative decline, and there are plenty of other markets out there. It might be painful but China could survive. In fact they, and other countries might just see it as the wake up call they needed to move beyond US hegemony.

The worrying thing is that whereas the US is in decline economically, it still has the largest military by orders of magnitude with bases round the globe. They may simply pursue “politics by other means”, as war of domination is sometimes described.

14

Narcissist challenges culture ingrained with the concept of “saving face” to perform humiliating retreat

by slimboyfat in

oh yeah, this is going to end well.

hold on to your seats, folks, we’re on the front row of history for, as the chinese might say, “interesting times”.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c8rgkkl7v8lo.

slimboyfat

Oh yeah, this is going to end well. 😮

Hold on to your seats, folks, we’re on the front row of history for, as the Chinese might say, “interesting times”.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c8rgkkl7v8lo

228

The point of existence and how it refutes the Trinity

by slimboyfat in

rowan williams, the former archbishop of canterbury gave an interesting answer to the somewhat stark question, what’s the point of us existing?

as a christian, my starting point is that we exist because the most fundamental form of activity, energy, call it what you like, that is there, is love.

that is, it’s a willingness that the other should be.

slimboyfat

Good point.

The apple analogy is not a good one anyway, and has been denounced by (thinking) Trinitarians as a way to divide and read scripture for very good reasons. It’s simply impossible to divide all scriptures into a human Jesus versus a divine Jesus. Many verses won’t fit into those orthodox slots.

Take John 10.18 itself for example. Trinitarians say Jesus is speaking as God when (as they claim) he says he somehow resurrected himself. But they say he is speaking as a human when he says he is commanded by God. So which is it, the human or the divine Jesus talking in this verse? It doesn’t work.

228

The point of existence and how it refutes the Trinity

by slimboyfat in

rowan williams, the former archbishop of canterbury gave an interesting answer to the somewhat stark question, what’s the point of us existing?

as a christian, my starting point is that we exist because the most fundamental form of activity, energy, call it what you like, that is there, is love.

that is, it’s a willingness that the other should be.

slimboyfat

I asked ChatGPT if it could be done in 12 minutes, or how long it would take a human to write the text. The response:

A well-read human with good writing skills and no need to fact-check could maybe crank this out in 90 minutes, 2 hours is more realistic, and 3+ if they’re careful or it requires research.

So 12 minutes? Still fantasy land.