I was also very surprised how the Amish boys are taught never to lie to anyone, so they confessed willingly and freely. In a way I feel badly for the boys who taught them this was allowed, I don't believe they were given any sex-ed either, they were left with no direction what to do with their hormones. Now they are in a prison system filled with men who are hard core criminals and they will be educated in prison about life. I think they deserved punishment, definitely, but it seems like it could all have been prevented with a bit of INFORMATION and COMMUNICATION as to what is right and what is wrong. Some limits and boundaries, some direction that the men were there to protect their sisters.
Maybe I am off-base, can you prevent molestation and incest? Could these boys raised in a more normal environment with other girls around have acted differently? Or is an abuser always going to abuse? It seemed like once the one boy did it, they all followed, then the younger boy molested his 4 year old sister. I'm not familiar enough with the mentality of a sexual molester to know if the abusers were "made" that way by their environment. As for them following the Bible strictly, I thought sinners were stoned to death. Where did this 6 week rule of shunning come in? That is the stupidest punishment I've ever heard of for rape.
One more point, these communities always put women second, they are second rate citizens, the motherrs, grandmothers, aunts, children, etc... and they have no place to turn. In communities where women are oppressed it seems like a license for the men to do whatever they want.