Hmmm,
I think I've somehow gotten off on the wrong foot here. I've been told that I sometimes manage to express my ideas in a way that can appear confrontational or adversarial. I'd just like to outright apologize unequivocally for that if that is the case here.
I don't have morbid curiosity in this topic, it is however very close to me for personal reasons that I will leave out of the discussion for now. Let me just say one thing: I HATE CHILD MOLESTERS. On good days I'd like to see them locked away for good, and on days where my bad nature gets the better of me I'd like to go a-huntin' for them with an assault rifle.
I would also like to state that in NO WAY do I disbelieve that Mr. Bowens life has been horribly affected by this issue. I would not even dream that he has forged these letters, and I don't believe I even hinted that in the least bit. If I came across that way I am very sorry, it was not my intent. I also do not disbelieve that he may have been harassed by elders who are either sadly confused or deluded about what they SHOULD be doing on this. I also don't disbelieve that given the chance to 'save the flock', they will try and get him booted, perhaps even ex-parte.
Here is what I do believe: that it will be difficult, and cmon, given the circumstances, it'd be hard for any of us in this situation, to report everything that is going on with it with complete objectivity. I also noticed some gaps in the paper trail, so to speak, and so just wanted to investigate a little more.
I also believe, and its not a phenomenon exclusive to xJw forums, that whenever someone builds a case such as Mr. Bowens has, that extremist nutbars will line up behind them without any real factual knowledge and make the wildest assertions in the name of supporting such a person. You are clearly not that type of person, I'm referring to someone who would say something like 'all elders are pedophiles'.
Here is what else I believe: if all this stuff is true, I think the name, address, and picture of every molester, the elders that protected them, and those who threatened his life, should be posted up for everyone to see so we can all be wary of. Call it a bit of naive mob justice attitude, I guess.
I also think that maybe, and I stress, just maybe, the gb, legal dept, the elders in question, whatever, are getting a huge amount of pressure because of the Dateline program and *just might* be saying (well not exactly, but in my words lol) "holy shit, this is hittin the fan big time and it's not going away, we'd better meet it square on before it gets any worse"...definately not the reason they SHOULD be hitting it head on, but as others have mentioned, at least now because of people like Mr. Bowens they HAVE to. So yeah, it'd be cool to stick it to 'em and make them squirm a bit, but if this is truly about protecting children (and I really have no doubts that it is for which Im glad), I'd be the bigger person, meet them halfway on the JC thing, get all my witnesses together and hit em head on.
The other side of me, of course, just feels like saying 'fuck em' and just not showing up at all. I did basically the same thing, back when I couldnt take the JC meetings anymore, and just told them to do whatever they wanted in my absence. They said it doesnt work like that, so I scribbled a goodbye note. And for people who really dont want to be a part of it anymore, thats always been my advice, just leave it behind. I realize thats not so simple in some cases, and quite apparently this is one of them.
Most of your points are good ones, and well taken. I certainly would not want people questioning my motives if I laid myself bare as he has done. I think because I do not know all the variables to Mr. Bowens situation it would have been better for me to shut up about it and just watch from the sidelines.
PS I take it Simon is the owner of the forum? Really, I just joined this week and don't know about all the politics of other people posing with different aliases. I would welcome such verification but I guess I'd hope that my email etc would remain private, right? One thing I can tell you is that while I may be outspoken and frequently have to rethink my positions, I will always post on this board with this name and this name only and would never mislead the board in any other manner.
--------------------------------------------------------------
"Well the God I believe in isn't short of cash, mister!"
Bullet the Blue Sky, Rattle n Hum version