Orobus,
"As for the misuse, it doesn't seem to be extremely eggregious and not on par with some of the deliberate misleading engaged in my the WT so I would hardly compare the two."
I wasn’t talking scale…I was talking method. The method the Watchtower uses in quoting scriptural passages and scientific statements entirely out of context is the exact method that Michael Moore is accused of using. The Sgt. was talking about the physical pain he was having and the new medication that was helping. The quote was used in a different context to make it appear as if the Sgt. was in extreme emotional pain for being abandoned by his government. (which he wasn’t) It would be like someone making a “documentary” about the Watchtower using snippets from various threads you wrote and using your words out of context to make it appear as if you were promoting the society. Do you think that you would be upset?
Abaddon,
"I remember the clip. It's borderline; one certainly is given an impression BUT that is not due to anything explict in the segment, and if it's not explcit I don't think he'll get anywhere"
Sorry, Abaddon, but this reminds me of someone defending the borg…ie: “er…well …they never actually came out and said that Armageddon was coming in 1975”
Then you did something else that jws do… try to switch the focus onto George Bush. Sorry, Abaddon, but even if everything MM claims is true, the methods he is accused of using will discredit whatever else he says. If it is proven that he deliberately deceived his audience about this instance, than it calls everything else he has said into question. Just like when we discovered one incident of deception in the Watchtower…and it made us question other issues as well….and it all fell like a house of cards.
What if someone used parts of threads you wrote, edited them in a such a way as to make it look like you are a huge supporter of George Bush, and then used that material to promote George Bush internationally? Would you take that lying down? Skillful editors can make black look like white and vice versa...which is why you have to be so careful these days as to who to believe.
Time will tell. The Sgt. will have his day in court. It will be an interesting case to follow.
Coffee