I agree to a point.
I, as a jdub, shunned others when confronted with it. But at least I was kind about it. I did it sheepishly, like I don't want to bu you know, I have to, sorry. The look.
So, I was a part of the problem and I knew the rules. I knew that could happen to me.
But on the other hand, I say that the way I acted was done in ignorance. I used to agree with shunning for a deliberate bad course taken and therefore a 'helpful' way to help that one see their error.
Now, I see it as a way for jdubs to insulate the group and to keep them all from discoverying the truth. I understand the shunning. It is hurtful. It is sad. My life has improved tremendously by getting OUT of jdub! Now, I look back and try to figure out a way to help them. I don't know if it will ever happen.
So, shunning is good for jdubs. It keeps them from learning all the great things I have learned. So, it is protecting the heard and accomplishing it's purpose. Unfortunately, that means that it hurts all it's members individually because it keeps them all in the dark.
Shunning is the price paid for leaving a cult. It is a heavy one at that. But it is worth every bit of pain for the freedom and joy and life that grows from each tear shed. That doesn't speak of hypocrasy. That speaks of the heart.