The events of 26th Dec. 2004 raise a difficult question for theism. I want to investigate possible answers.--cofty
Although you might not be investigating along the fairly broad range that I am exploring, here are my thoughts:
Increasingly I am attracted to the simple theism the Jarawa tribe has found: the sea god tries to eat them. Apparently they don't have theologians clever enough to talk them out of this point of view.
That said, they probably would get a kick out of hearing Job argue with his Theo about a particular natural event--a cyclone.
The book of Job (the fellow wasn't an Israelite, btw) seems to have had somewhat the same uneasy feelings of Theo after the cyclone. After all, he had grown up with conventional views of Theo (though, when pressed on the matter, he confessed to certain observations of Theo's unfairness). But Job didn't find Theo to be very kind even though Job was very considerate of Theo. A cyclone killed all his children and left him with a wife that was even less impressed with Theo than he was. We all remember her advice: "Curse God and die!"
The book is a paean (sp?) to the power of Nature--and the unknowable-ness of Theo.
I have read that the ancient editors of the OT in David's court didn't touch the Book of Job. The old story is cryptic and misfit. Although it looks to me that the editors went ahead to ascribe motive to Theo's actions, talked about the courts of heaven, Satan, etc. But all we hear from Job is that his family's the disaster left him speechless after the event.
That was honest.
I would love to know what he said to his wife. and that is the problem, isn't it?
I would love to know what the Jarawans would say about this story.
I search for that answer myself.