HI Fresia
My point is that I look at the fruitage, and indeed JW do display what Jesus said was the identifying mark of a true Christian.
But only as far as the Society allow them to show that love. The vast majority of JW's are lovely people, friendly helpful, sociable etc, they try and live moral lives (but like everyone else, fail sometimes) Would you agree that when it comes to obeying a ruling from the Society, the lovely people seem to disappear replaced by people who HAVE to be seen to be obedient?
For example I had been a member of my congregation for 21 years when I left 1 year ago. I know personally all the witnesses in my area and counted them as very good friends. I regularly see them and give them a smile. I know in their heart of hearts they are very loving people, yet these same people are told to suppress their own natural friendliness and love and ignore me as if I'm dead. And they do.
Why? Because the Society has decreed that because I no longer want to be a witness, I am to be shunned. I am still a christian, I still am happily married, I take care of my aged parents and my young family, I work hard, I don't swear, smoke or drink (to excess) Yet I am to be treated with contempt.
So Yes up to a point I can agree, the witnesses do display the fruitage of love, but if a society rule conflicts with showing that love, the rule comes first every time. Would you agree that this is true?
I can't help but recall Jesus words at Matt 9 v 13 "I want mercy and not sacrifice"