Are the witnesses wrong for not celebrating these festivals as this whole thread implies?
Reinaa, the WTS are wrong in the context of not allowing the individual to make a personal decission especially when the Scriptures are silent on the matter.
Should the WTS outlaw Christmas or leave it to the conscience of the individual as to how or even if they should celebrate it?
I don't celebrate Christmas Reinaa nor am I interested in celebrating it but the issue is that the WTS denies its members the freedom of choice and that is such a contrast to the reasonableness that Russell displayed, namely:
"Christmas Day, in celebration of our dear Redeemer's birth, has for centuries been celebrated on Dec. 25; and although it is now well known that this date is in error...nevertheless, since the Lord has given no instructions whatever upon this subject, and since it is proper to do good deeds and think good thoughts upon any day, it cannot be improper, ...for us to remember in a social way our dear Redeemer's birth at this time."(Zion's WT, Dec. 15, 1898-pg.370).
"It matters not particularly that Dec. 25 is not the anniversary of our Lord's birth, according to the Scriptural account; that really He was born about September 25, nine months later. One day, as well as another, will serve us to commemorate our Savior's birth in the flesh, as a gift of God's love to a condemned and dying world."(Zion's WT, Dec. 15, 1908-pg.379).