I'm awake, hermana. And also stunned by the points you make.
I started doubting the organization long ago, and those doubts have only grown and turned into certainties (and not good certainties!).
But only recently have started to have bigger doubts, about the whole big picture. My beef is with Human suffering, although you make a great point about animal suffering.
I've always bought into the "Porque permite Dios el sufrimiento?" explanation. But in the past few years I've grown sensitive to the issue. A girl abducted and raped 3 times a day, every day, for nine months... Thousands dying of hunger, literally fading and losing their tissue to starvation, little by little, eternal second by eternal second... I just can't take it. When I add all the human suffering (that I'm aware of), I just can't see how it is loving to let that go for thousands of year only so God can make his point in his case against Satan? Forgive me Lord, but I don't get it.
We are told we have to see the bigger picture: that 9 months, or a few years are nothing to the eternal and almighty. But doesn't the point of view of those suffering count? It's just horrible, and yet we don't know all that's going on.
Explanations like "All will be resurrected", "Eternal youth and health and happiness are worth this", "This is temporary", "For God 1000 years is like a day", "God knows you better and he only lets you be tested as far as you can resist"... to me all has grown hollow, and senseless. Self-serving hollow phrases.
Believe me Goldensky, I understand you more than you think. I'm in, and don't know what to do.