Why, if she was killed, would this case merit special commemoration?
I would think that being killed would more likely result in special commemoration than just being sent to a nunnery. If it was just that, then why not have four days a year for all the nuns?
BTW, I missed one point in the above thread - IIRC, didn't the WT somehow hint that the father knew that it would likely be the daughter who would come out and greet him? I remember them saying that it probably was a conscious decision on his part to pick his favorite daughter.
Didn't they also try to make a link from this to parents who "give up" their kids to go to Bethel or Pioneer?
Pretty sicko notions all of it, IMHO.