I feel like the elders in this case didn't know their own rules. Instead of bothering to figure it out they just let the poor dub suffer knowing he has to suck it up and wait on Jehovah.
Elders (including the FDS) make mistakes
Wait on Jehovah!
RNF dubs make mistakes.
Three elders drag you into a judicial hearing because when they get together Jehovah answers them instantly.