You Know,
Obviously apostate dubs at one time did believe that there was a solid foundation of our faith otherwise you wouldn't have spent those many years trying to convince others that you had the truth. - - You Know
I'm not sure if I fit the definition of an apostate since I never believed anything the JWs forced down my throat as a child. I never had any inclination whatsoever to get baptized or in any way remain with the JWs beyond the age where my parents could compel me to attend meetings and perform uncompensated marketing services for the WTS corporation(s). If you consider me to be an "apostate," then your above-quoted assumption is absolutely invalid as it pertains to me. I spent "many years trying to convince others that [I] had the truth," only because I was coerced under the threat of severe beatings to perform such uncompensated marketing services. Therefore, in my case, not only was there not "solid foundation" for faith, but there never was any faith to speak of. Instead, there was the misery of a young child exploited for the benefit of a corporation cult.
Many of you were elders, ministerial servants, pioneers, and some even anointed. Where you that stupid? - - You Know [sic]
Unfortunately, for those who at one time believed but no longer have faith in the Watchtower cult, the answer to that question is "yes." That's why many are here, to vent or to find other ways to cope with their mistakes. At some point I bet you too will be here for that purpose, instead of the gadfly purpose that you now serve (and quite successfully, given the typically substantial number of replies to your posts).
Ironically, one of the strongest evidences that we do indeed possess the true faith is the existence of apostates themselves. - - You Know
That is extremely fallacious reasoning, You Know. That's like a person suffering from delusions claiming that the existence of people who reject his/her version of reality somehow prove that his/her version of reality is accurate. LOL.
One of the great ironies of the apostate movement, that presumptuously boasts of "know the truth about the truth," is that apostates themselves are bound by the Watchtower's own interpretive shortcomings, and hence are massively ignorant of Jehovahs judicial decisions regarding his organization. In what way? In that the presumption in operation is that if enough scandal and error can be brought to light regarding the Governing Body, the Watchtower Society's teachings, as well as individual Jehovah's Witnesses, then that somehow means that Jehovah's Witnesses have no connection with Jehovah God.
You Know, you have presumed a presumption. Scandal is merely one factor among many that support skepticism of an organization that represents itself as the sole mouthpiece of god. There are many more, including without limitation the preaching of intolerance of others, shunning of family members who don't share cult beliefs - - leading to destruction of the family unit, illogical interpretation of biblical standards regarding blood transfusions and cigarette smoking, etc.
It takes a lot of faith to believe what the JWs are preaching. Like many others here, I am a skeptic, not a pigeon. I think that in some ways you are too, and I welcome the day when you join the ranks of the folks you unsuccessfully attempt to discredit here.
Edited to correct typos - additions are underlined, deletions are stricken through.
Edited by - 144001 on 17 July 2002 12:33:19
Edited by - 144001 on 17 July 2002 14:53:15